Surely, you would not try to sell the church of Barcarus an item (the candlestick) that was obviously stolen from them at some point in the past.
If you were to seek a blackmarket value for the candlestick you can probably get 3,000 gp for it--retail cost 6k. I assume that information might be useful in figuring shares. It is indeed a custom item.
Hey, just because it has a holy symbol on it doesn't mean to me that it was stolen, just 'acquired through an active lifestyle' (aka adventuring).
OK, I have tabulated the values and here's what I get. Without the candlestick the total retail value of our 'Lewt' is 107,170 gp. That makes the pure cash value 53,585. If we divide it by 8 that would make each share 6,801.875 gp. (ie 6,801 gp, 8 sp, 7.5 cp).
[SBLOCK="Item Breakdown"]
Magical Weapons
Bastard Sword +2 Whirling = 18335 gp;
Lesser Energy Assault Crystal = 3000 gp;
Cleaver, Life Drinker = 40300 gp;
Mighty [+2] Composite Elvencraft Longbow +2 = 8900 gp;
Arrows +1 Flaming = 40 gp * 7 = 280 gp;
Masterwork Arrows = 6 gp * 2 = 12 gp;
Dagger +1 = 2302 gp;
Magical Armor
Chain Shirt +1 Light Fortification = 4250 gp;
Leather Armor +2 = 4160 gp;
Magical Items
Rod of Wonder = 12000 gp;
Rod of Frost = 1400 gp; '(MIC p.174)
Ring of Protection +1 = 2000 gp;
Scroll = (3 + 3 + 2) * 8 * 25 = 1600 gp; 'Greater Mage Armor, Hold Person, and Bear's Endurance @ lvl 8
Ray of Ice Wand = ( (2 * 3 * 750) / 50) * 13 = 1170 gp;
Everburning Torch = 110 gp;
Potions
Porcupine Elixer = 800 gp; '(MIC p.169)
Flaming Fists Elixer = 300; '(MIC p.159)
Oil of Bless Weapon = 50 gp;
Cure Serious Wounds = 750 gp;
Cats Grace = 300 gp;
Cure Light Wounds = 50 gp * 2 = 100 gp;
Mundane Items
Masterwork Dagger = 302 gp;
Masterwork Light Crossbow = 335 gp;
Master Warhammer = 312 gp;
Heavy Crossbows = 50 gp * 2 = 100 gp;
Short Swords = 10 gp * 12 = 120 gp;
Spears = 2 gp * 10 = 20 gp;
Chainmail = 150 gp * 20 = 3000 gp;
Light and Heavy Shields = (9 gp * 4) + (20 gp * 4) = 36 gp + 80 gp = 116 gp;
Half Plate = 600 gp;
Daggers = 2 gp * 3 = 6 gp;
Alchemists Fire = 20 gp * 3 = 60 gp;
Thunderstone = 30 gp;
Tanglefoot Bag = 50 gp;
Cash and Jewels = 830 gp;[/SBLOCK]
EDIT: For the prices listed only half of it counts towards your share.