Meh, I like this place. This seems like a premature evacuation.
*pause for laughter*
It's a bit rough around the edges, but it's not toxic by a longshot. I earned my posting chops on a different board that was as strictly moderated as humanly possible, so while people get away with stuff here that does rub me the wrong way occasionally, most folk are civil and seem to promote worthwhile discussion. The topics definitely revolve more around strict rules debate than discussion of actual gameplay or roleplaying, but that's cool by me, helps me keep myself sharp at the table since I'm my groups DM.
Plus, like, look at this thread... people here have a damn fine sense of humor.