The PDF Review Project

[JoeGKushner]

The only potential problem I see, if with the "big" books getting knocked off the list quickly due to rapid reviews being entered into the system. It's a little easier to review the PDF's in terms of their overall size, then say something like Shackled City.

 

[reveal]

Ok. My first review is up. Bardic Lore: Ogham. Very cool book.

 

[reveal]

Quick question: Do we have to notify anyone of a new review so it can be listed on the front page? Or is someone notified of a new review automatically?

 

[Crothian]

Quick question: Do we have to notify anyone of a new review so it can be listed on the front page? Or is someone notified of a new review automatically?

Newshounds take care of that as far as I know. Sometimes a review gets pass them, but not often.

 

[Crothian]

The only potential problem I see, if with the "big" books getting knocked off the list quickly due to rapid reviews being entered into the system. It's a little easier to review the PDF's in terms of their overall size, then say something like Shackled City.

This is nothing new though. Getting more reviews is a good thing and we just need to figure a way to make sure people can find them after a few days.

 

[JoeGKushner]

This is nothing new though. Getting more reviews is a good thing and we just need to figure a way to make sure people can find them after a few days.

Not disagreeing that it's nothing new, but if the volume increases dramatically due to more review copies going out, the problem has escalated.

 

[Mercule]

I just emailed you with my ideas/requirements/whatever the right word is.

 

[reveal]

I just emailed you with my ideas/requirements/whatever the right word is.

The password is "plethora."

 

[Crothian]

Not disagreeing that it's nothing new, but if the volume increases dramatically due to more review copies going out, the problem has escalated.

WEll, hopefully something can be done. The review side has been dead most of this year and needed an influx of reviews to get back to were it was. We are just seeing problems that were there but because of the lack of reviews was not as noticible. Personally, I like that we are finally getting reviews from awider variety of people. This has opened the door to a lot of people who have been thinking about doing reviews and just needed a little push.

 

[der_kluge]

Of them, NONE became actual reviews. Not one.

That's too bad. I'd be more than happy to review if you send me a copy. (not that it's going to do any good at this stage of the game...)

I'm gonna see if I can do a HARP review next. Sure, Crothian. Give me an easy one, why don't ya!