Horwath
Legend
anything that is not a full caster cannot be overpoweredThe conversation was about making the Ranger get magic as a subclass. @Micah Sweet said they would be preferable.
I said that Wildborn Ranger is a 1/3 caster while the WOTC Ranger is a 1/2 caster. So the player who wants a magical ranger loses out to please the needs of the players who wants a non spellcasting one. You'd have to make the Wildborn a 1/2 caster to please both sides
However a 1/2 caster Wildborn A5e Ranger is very likely Overpowered all the way from level 1.
