Myrdin Potter
Hero
I prefer the current system of the bonuses being tied to the race you chose. If you don't want to min max, you can still play whatever class you want, just that some races are a more natural fit. However, I have zero problem with just making the bonuses floating. You character is already going to be an exception, so why not?
I think there is way to much angst over possible parallels to non-game issues, and not enough focus on the game itself.
My daughter plays a Goblin Bard in my campaign. No charisma boost, but so what? She enjoys the role playing and fun of playing a goblin out in society trying to be different. It probably is more fun for her that way. With a floating bonus, she could have the typical very high Charisma score but it really is not needed.
I think there is way to much angst over possible parallels to non-game issues, and not enough focus on the game itself.
My daughter plays a Goblin Bard in my campaign. No charisma boost, but so what? She enjoys the role playing and fun of playing a goblin out in society trying to be different. It probably is more fun for her that way. With a floating bonus, she could have the typical very high Charisma score but it really is not needed.