Well, on damage isues, I got this house full of MM orcs and a party of 2nd lvel pcs was cornering them, one of the rogues (there were two) decided to check the window open at the second floor, he threw his rope, went up.
To make sure nothing was ready to get him, he passed a dagger in front of the window, i though "damn bad archer in there, he reacts and hits on a 20 only", I roll the die and... hit.
In disbelief the rogue throws the dagger with an arrow attached to its pummel inside the window and gets another one. again I decide the orc can hit only on a 20... and he hits!
The players were all in disbelief, the one of the rogue said that phrase: "It is an orc, of course he has roled 2 20s, he can't do that again." And so, he peeks through the window, I roll a dice and it comes another 20, the critical confirmed, we did not use instant kils at that game.
Result is a description of him peking and slowly seeing the orc and a bow, ending up in an arrow aligned perfectly with his eye and the orc's, a shot and a hit that dropped him to around -8.
Man, if I was then like I am now, that orc would have gained around 3 fighter levels for an archer npc....
