Worst Value for Money RPG Purchase

Penumbra Fantasy Bestiary, hands down. It was a big deal how it was one of the most expensive gaming books of its day, but was chock full of material... that was poorly playtested and edited and I found fairly uninspired. Ne'er once did I actually use it, and I sold it about a year ago. Didn't even like reading the thing, and I love monster books!

Now, with the Monster Geographica series, I can use the majority of those monsters if I ever decide they'd be useful... for a tiny sliver of the cost, and a lot more, better monsters besides.

Demiurge out.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

This is part of the reason that even though my disposable income has gone up 2,000% or so since 3rd ed came out my actual gaming spending has actually decreased by 50%.

Yup. Me too. Burned on some unbelievably shoddy 3rd party books and now pretty much refuse to buy any without major research into it beforehand. I'm definitely in the same boat.
 


Worst Waste of Money: Fast Forward Entertainment, again. I knew the stats for their Devils/Demons books were bad, but I at least thought the fluuf might add something. My mistake.

Dishonorable Mentions: The 2e splatbooks (Fighters Handbook, Thieves Handbook, etc). Actually, pretty much anything to do with 2e, except for the campaign-specific material. Planescape and (some of) Ravenloft were awesome... and although I never played them, there were cool things about Dark Sun, Spelljammer, etc. But the non-setting-specific modules, the splatbooks, the ring-bound monster manuals... [shudder]...

...ooh,ooh! And that Pool of Radiance computer game. The 3e version, not the original Gold Box version. Man, I hated that game.

Worst Waste of Money for a WotC 3e Rulebook: Deities and Demigods. The art is lovely to look at, but everything else is just... bleh.
 

I'm sorry, but I got Penumbra Fantasy Bestiary from a hater used and loved it and used it more than many Monster Manuals. Definately disagree with you, Demiurge.
I never really had a poor purchase, or a purchase that I've deeply regretted. The closest is the download of the World of Warcraft RPG I made but that has nothing to do with the quality of the product, its fantastic, and everything to do with how I can never set up or get into a game that uses it.
 



Legend of the Five Rings 3rd edition

I spent the time between TSR D&D and WotC D&D in Rokugan and loved it and I especially loved it when L5R went D20. But when I tried to go back to other system, I just missed all the options that D20 offers. I like the idea of Fox clan as Rangers, a Crane clan Psychic Warrior samurai and all the other options. I still say the 5 level Prestige classes in all of the Way of ____ books are the truest to what Prestige classes were supposed to be in 3e.

I do wish AEG would let someone release some more D20 Rokugan books.
 

Epic Level Handbook . . . or maybe the Planar Handbook. Neither are really bad books, I've just never had any use for them, probably because I generally dislike all high-level games.
 

Occult Items of Power by Fast Forward entertainment.

It's a train wreck.

1. 127 pages long (slim volume) cost? $24.95 For 19 cents a page, i would hope for something decent, right? ... right?

The entirety of the books crunchy contents fit on 8 pages. EIGHT pages of actual original material. How do I know this? because the "index of Occult items" in the back takes exactly eight pages.

the other 119?

- "Illustrations" of the "occult items". which look suspiciously like ordinary photos of things you would buy at Hot Topic and Spencer Gifts. (seriously, look...)

698.jpg


This candlestick, this precise candle stick is statted up in the book.

The candle has different functions that vary based on what kind of candle you burn in it. You have to make a candle especially for this object to work, you have to sepnd between 250 gp and 2,000 gp to get any special effects out of it. Other candles put into the candlestick offend it, causing it to emit a firey burst of 2d10 damage to the person who lit the inferior candle.

It's an intelligent light source ladies and gentlemen, that's snooty.

- Long, aggressively long "histories" of the items, written by 5th-rate fantasy hacks.

Please consider the following character description.

Delilah was a weaver by trade, and her home was modest. The rumor was that she was the daughter of a king from the west, but she had borne Parnopius out of wedlock and had been disowned. She came to Sophos village empty handed and bearing a newborn. Though many men had been willing to mary the beautiful girl, Delilah prefered to make her own home and live out her days without a husband.nearly twenty years had passed, but her beauty still turned heads when she went around in public

Sound like a mary-sue? Yeah, there's lots of that in this book. Bad fantasy and worse faux-historical stories fluff out each entry, sometimes these stories are only tangentially connected to the artifact in question. Most of the time, they go on for two full pages, while the item itself gets squeezed into a tiny column.

-Incidentally, all the items in the book are ARTIFACTS. every last one. they all have "unique" powers or abilities (nevermind the fact that half of them are weaker than regular magic items found in the DMG. For example, who wants a wall-sconce candle that creates an area of "see invisibility" within 20 feet of it's light... if it has to be fastened to a wall for it to work?) so good luck working these things into a regular campaign.

In short: too expensive + too much fluff + Too much BAD fluff + really, really poorly though out = Damnit! i can't believe i bought this thing!
 

Remove ads

Top