Parmandur
Book-Friend
It's not on a hit.
-
The VOIDRUNNER'S CODEX is LIVE! Explore new worlds, fight oppressive empires, fend off fearsome aliens, and wield deadly psionics with this comprehensive boxed set expansion for 5E and A5E!
D&D 4E Ben Riggs' "What the Heck Happened with 4th Edition?" seminar at Gen Con 2023
- Thread starter Alzrius
- Start date
D&D has a long tradition of using hit points as more than just "hits to kill" however. For example, the Wilderness Survival Guide tells me that I'm at risk of taking a point of damage every 3 turns for having the nerve to walk around in 85 degree weather!
There have totally been spells that require an attack roll and then allowed a save for reduced damage. I don't see how one is perfectly fine and the other is somehow ridiculous.
EDIT: I suppose you're right, that's not precisely the same thing. But we do have instances in 5e of effects that still deal damage if you miss. For example, let's look at Lightning Arrow.
Last edited:
Parmandur
Book-Friend
To be fair, that does actually work under a strict "HP as meat" read of the rules.
Except the book was printed in the same edition where the DMG tells us HP are not meat, lol. Either way, the nature of hit points has been a grey area for a long time and I don't really see how 4e was somehow worse than most other editions in this regard.
Or put another way, it's like saying everything since the original D&D has been all downhill, lol.
Verisimilitude means the property of seeming true or real.
Your interpretation of AD&D hp does not seem very verisimilitudinous to me; nor to Gygax, I assume, hence his account of hp which is different from yours.
Lanefan
Victoria Rules
Have you never had one of those headaches that hangs on for a few days? That psionic (or illusion-caused) pain could very easily map to such a thing, only brought on by a different cause.
And the Cleric's packing a whole bag of Aspirin!
Lanefan
Victoria Rules
All hit points coming back after a good 8 hours sleep - even if you were at death's door a few times during the previous day - makes no sense. It takes the gamist abstraction that we all kinda have to accept and dials it up to eleven.
Some small fraction of your hit points coming back over that same 8 hours rest does make sense; 1e's natural rest rate of 1 point a day went too far the other way (and, in the process, treated all hit points as meat for purposes of natural recovery time). And it should be a set fraction such that everyone, regardless of their total hit points, takes roughly the same amount of time to recover (though I could very easily see putting a species-based modifier on that, using the rationale that some species simply heal up/regenerate a bit faster than others).
Lanefan
Victoria Rules
Not familiar with either of those spells; but were it me writing them those spells would pack some damage with them.
Lanefan
Victoria Rules
Whenever save-for-half comes into play, it almost always means you've been caught in a big enough area of some damaging effect that you couldn't escape it entirely.
I've always seen save-for-half as, in part, a convenient shortcut to take the place of rolling up the damage separately for each being in the area, which would be more realistic but would also sometimes involve a LOT of dice-rolling!
The one that sticks in my simulationist craw a little is 'evasion', where someone (usually a Monk) in the area takes no damage at all on a save.
