D&D 5E Being strong and skilled is a magic of its own or, how I learned to stop worrying and love anime fightin' magic

[DND_Reborn]

I'm sure a rhino would hit harder with a magic sword too. This is not a valid argument.

Clearly you missed this part, so I'll reiterate for your benefit:

Ditto, so let's just drop it? I really don't want to have to use the Ignore feature.

 

[Scribe]

And yet you can flip a guy who weighs 3x as much as you over your shoulder. And you aren't as strong as a rhino.

Yes, but that's...not measure of strength, or even skill. To do it against a similarly skilled and antagonistic opponent, sure, but....the act of executing a throw or trip, is not particularly mythical.

Going for an ankle, and then heaving your 20 foot tall monstrosity opponent around and through its minions, is a whole different thing.

 

[FireLance]

The traditional way in which fighters remain "non-magical" while still contributing at the same level as magic-users was for them to get magical equipment.

Picking up Orcus and bowling him into his minions gets more plausible if the fighter has a girdle of storm giant strength. BMX Bandit can close the power gap with Angel Summoner if he was riding Street Hawk (an all-terrain attack motorcycle designed to fight urban crime, capable of incredible speeds up to three hundred miles an hour, and immense firepower - from Wikipedia).

The downside to this approach is that handing out magic items has traditionally been the province of the DM (or the module, or random loot tables). Previous attempts to cede even this amount of narrative control to the players (or even to ask what the players want via wish lists) have been met with hostility. I think this point needs to be made more clearly and explicitly.

 

[Haplo781]

The traditional way in which fighters remain "non-magical" while still contributing at the same level as magic-users was for them to get magical equipment.

Picking up Orcus and bowling him into his minions gets more plausible if the fighter has a girdle of storm giant strength. BMX Bandit can close the power gap with Angel Summoner if he was riding Street Hawk (an all-terrain attack motorcycle designed to fight urban crime, capable of incredible speeds up to three hundred miles an hour, and immense firepower - from Wikipedia).

The downside to this approach is that handing out magic items has traditionally been the province of the DM (or the module, or random loot tables). Previous attempts to cede even this amount of narrative control to the players (or even to ask what the players want via wish lists) have been met with hostility. I think this moint needs to be made more clearly and explicitly.

Yeah, playing "DM may I" to be able to do anything fun ain't it, especially when it's only certain classes that have to do so.

 

[Haplo781]

Yes, but that's...not measure of strength, or even skill. To do it against a similarly skilled and antagonistic opponent, sure, but....the act of executing a throw or trip, is not particularly mythical.

Going for an ankle, and then heaving your 20 foot tall monstrosity opponent around and through its minions, is a whole different thing.

Counterpoint:

 

[Maxperson]

PS - we only play with wizards and druids in our game, so there are only two PC caster class

Out of curiosity, why no clerics?

 

[Haplo781]

I uh, had a thought, which is substantial enough for its own thread.

 

[Maxperson]

Sufficiently advanced marital ability is indistinguishable from magic.

My wife certainly gets me to do things like magic.

 

[Dannyalcatraz]

Clearly you missed this part, so I'll reiterate for your benefit:

Mod Note:

Use or use not ignore function. Do not threaten.

 

[Umbran]

Clearly you've never done judo

Clearly, you are using an attempt at humor to deflect from actually dealing with the point made. Your avoidance is noted.

By the way, while shotokan was more my speed, I have done a bit of judo cross training.