I am not sure it's a case of "two personalities vying for supremacy". Retaining the hunger and need for blood isn't the same as having another personality.
In the case of Angel, in fact, having it be two personalities vying for control is not consistent with it being a curse. Angel is cursed not only with having a soul, but with the fact that if he ever actually feels true happiness, the curse ends - releasing a beast. If occasionally that beast had a chance at control, how long would he have kept such a curse? Like the beast isn't gonna go out and be happy right quick? Consider early on when we'd posit the beast would have a greter relative strength...
The issue is that in the Buffyverse, having a soul is at least partially equivalent to having a conscience. When you get a conscience back after a couple centuries of being a cruel and sadistic bloodsucking monster, your sanity is gong to be strained.
Before becoming a vampire, William the Bloody Awful Poet was a sensitive person. That sensitive person, faced with what he's done for so many years, snapped like a twig. It may take some time to put himself back together.
In the case of Angel, in fact, having it be two personalities vying for control is not consistent with it being a curse. Angel is cursed not only with having a soul, but with the fact that if he ever actually feels true happiness, the curse ends - releasing a beast. If occasionally that beast had a chance at control, how long would he have kept such a curse? Like the beast isn't gonna go out and be happy right quick? Consider early on when we'd posit the beast would have a greter relative strength...
The issue is that in the Buffyverse, having a soul is at least partially equivalent to having a conscience. When you get a conscience back after a couple centuries of being a cruel and sadistic bloodsucking monster, your sanity is gong to be strained.
Before becoming a vampire, William the Bloody Awful Poet was a sensitive person. That sensitive person, faced with what he's done for so many years, snapped like a twig. It may take some time to put himself back together.
Last edited: