City Survivor - Final Vote! (Read the Question before voting!!!!)

[Desdichado]

I voted Sigil because at least in Sigil I wouldn't have to worry about an avatar of knocking down my door or high jacking my pirate ship..... Hmmm... but then when you think about it a naval battle between Mi-go Pirates and the Imperial Navy of the Yellow Sign would be kind of cool..

I think I'm in love...

 

[GlassJaw]

Freeport FTW!!

 

[Vyvyan Basterd]

Alas, I must vote for the Restaurant at the End of the Universe, um I mean the Star Wars Cantina, no I mean, drat!

I guess I should vote for it because I liked Robin Williams in the Bird Cage. And who can resist the ultimate in phallic symbols, the infinite spire. And you gotta love a place where the NPCs and real life fans treat those who don't know the city like clueless inferiors.

Or I could vote for a city of pirates...

In true Survivor fashion I ask both sides a question:

Freeport Fans --> What makes your city any different from other pirate holds? What makes it better than the Hold of the Sea Princes or the Scarlet Brotherhood in Greyhawk?

Planscape Fans --> What do you think makes Freeport better than Greyhawk City (since we know it was PS fans voting against GH)?

 

[Rystil Arden]

Alas, I must vote for the Restaurant at the End of the Universe, um I mean the Star Wars Cantina, no I mean, drat!

I guess I should vote for it because I liked Robin Williams in the Bird Cage. And who can resist the ultimate in phallic symbols, the infinite spire. And you gotta love a place where the NPCs and real life fans treat those who don't know the city like clueless inferiors.

Or I could vote for a city of pirates...

In true Survivor fashion I ask both sides a question:

Freeport Fans --> What makes your city any different from other pirate holds? What makes it better than the Hold of the Sea Princes or the Scarlet Brotherhood in Greyhawk?

Planscape Fans --> What do you think makes Freeport better than Greyhawk City (since we know it was PS fans voting against GH)?

Well, I've been voting against Greyhawk city since I saw this survivor series (midway through) because it is boring, vanilla, blase, and underspecified. I am also a Planescape fan, but I voted against GC before I saw that Sigil was in trouble.

 

[nvrtrustanelf]

I have voted because my DM hath commanded... also in hopes that my character will live to see lvl 6.

 

[Shadeydm]

They both suck no thanks.

 

[Desdichado]

In true Survivor fashion I ask both sides a question:

Freeport Fans --> What makes your city any different from other pirate holds? What makes it better than the Hold of the Sea Princes or the Scarlet Brotherhood in Greyhawk?

Planscape Fans --> What do you think makes Freeport better than Greyhawk City (since we know it was PS fans voting against GH)?

I think you greatly overestimate the importance of your single vote!

 

[Vyvyan Basterd]

I think you greatly overestimate the importance of your single vote!

Hey! I was raised American. Every vote counts. Right? Right!?

And don't change the subject just because you don't want to answer the question.

Besides, you never know. Greyhawk fans looking for revenge, Freeport fans, and Planescape fans that think they are voting off Freeport. It could add up.

 

[Desdichado]

Besides, you never know. Greyhawk fans looking for revenge, Freeport fans, and Planescape fans that think they are voting off Freeport. It could add up.

Yeah, and the last round switch from voting off to voting to keep is the "pregnant chads" of ENW D&D survivor.

 

[Ambrus]

Planscape Fans --> What do you think makes Freeport better than Greyhawk City (since we know it was PS fans voting against GH)?

I've at least seen and held various Freeport related supplements in my hands; even if I haven't read them. As far as I know, Greyhawk city has never been detailed or featured in its own supplement. I figure it probably has some kind of coverage at some point, but I've never seen or held such a book so I wouldn't call it accessible or even popular.

I've also never played Greyhawk and have never read or heard anything about the setting that would make me want to; it seems rather bland. I did read through the first few Freeport adventures and they seemed okay. I simply remember thinking to myself that Freeport itself seemed interesting enough, though I felt it lacked more detail to make it live. That was before the Freeport supplements were released.