D&D (2024) D&D 2024 PHB errata thread +

pukunui

Legend
It does if you Telekenitic pull them into it.
Hmm. OK. That wasn't something I ever saw in play.

Dropping a weapon was free in 2014. It isn't now so that only works if the free object interaction can be used to draw or drop a weapon or swap hands. I think the two weapon fighting rules require you to have a second light weapon in your other hand and the nick property tags on from that. So I'm not 100% sure that the absence of mentioning the other hand on the nick specialty makes much difference overall. You have to start off with two weapons, drop one as part of the first attack, swap as an object interaction for your free nick attack. Only fighter types would then be able to draw a third weapon as part of extra attack.
No, they don't! They just require it to be a different weapon. They have removed the "other hand" wording. That's why this is a potential issue. I don't expect we'll get actual errata for it, but I would like some sage advice from Jeremy to see what his intent was at the very least.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Belen

Hero
And Samsung sold a phone for $849.99 that exploded so much it was discontinued after two months.

I get it is fashionable to hate WoTC for being an evil corporation, and yes, they should not get a free pass on errors, but let's stop acting like "if they had just put in effort, there would have been zero mistakes, this is all because they hate putting in effort"
Feel free to dismiss my comments by implying that I hate WOTC.

People were finding big problems before we got the books.

I have worked in publishing for 25 years so I get that the books have been printed for a while but 2024 is showing a lot of signed of rush despite a long public play test.

I support them quite often but I am not enthused with 5.5.
 

Pauln6

Hero
Hmm. OK. That wasn't something I ever saw in play.


No, they don't! They just require it to be a different weapon. They have removed the "other hand" wording. That's why this is a potential issue. I don't expect we'll get actual errata for it, but I would like some sage advice from Jeremy to see what his intent was at the very least.
I think it's valid to ask why they removed the line. Two weapon fighting is clearly meant and always has been fighting with two weapons at the same time so that's the default. They may have wanted to leave open a scenario where you might want to swap hands during combat (but this is essentially drawing a weapon so is still covered by the once per attack rule). But since you can presumably draw a weapon with your bonus attack it still falls in the cracks.

You can potentially benefit from TWF and duelist at the same time with a strict interpretation, which should explain why it won't be intended.

The question is whether you can ALSO draw/stow/drop a weapon as a free interaction? In combat, I would probably say no.
 

FrogReaver

As long as i get to be the frog
Anyone with multi-attack can do it every other turn.
Fighter 11 has enough swaps to do it every turn.
Or even Fighter 2 with action surge.
Or Haste.
I don’t think you understood my point because you aren’t addressing it at all. What’s the sequence to use a shield in one hand, swap weapons such that you maximize the atttacks with vex and still get to make a free action attack due to the light property and the Nick mastery? How many attacks with vex is that?
 

UngainlyTitan

Legend
Supporter
Feel free to dismiss my comments by implying that I hate WOTC.

People were finding big problems before we got the books.

I have worked in publishing for 25 years so I get that the books have been printed for a while but 2024 is showing a lot of signed of rush despite a long public play test.

I support them quite often but I am not enthused with 5.5.
I do not think it is rushed, so much as Wizards of the Coast management, like a lot of modern publishers undervalue editing and copy editing in particular and under resource this aspect of the publishing process.
 




mellored

Legend
2024 is showing a lot of signed of rush despite a long public play test.
It definitely seems like it was rushed after playtest 8 IMO.

Like people thought they still had another week to work on it, but a manager said "you have till the end of the day".
 

Pauln6

Hero
Tbh, the draw and stow two weapons in dual wield seems a bit redundant now too. It should probably be draw a weapon as part of your attack action. Then on thrown weapons confirm that you can draw a thrown weapon as part of the attack.
 

Split the Hoard


Split the Hoard
Negotiate, demand, or steal the loot you desire!

A competitive card game for 2-5 players
Remove ads

Top