I watched the first hour of it, since I'm a fan of Matt Colville's and Kickstarted the stream. This is still longer than I've watched Critical Role or any other D&D stream.
I liked that it "felt" more like a real D&D game than a bunch of actors doing voices. I had to stop listening due to real world obligations, and was planning on getting back into it until I started reading the negative comments about the extent of the railroad, the Kobayashi Maru set up, etc. All this seems contrary to Colville's DMing advice and it sounds like a poor game overall. As a player, I doubt I would return after a first session like that.