Dislike 4E? You can write off 5E

rounser

First Post
I read Wyatt's interview and he said 5e will be much similar to 4e than 3e to 4e.
Thought this needed a thread of it's own. No end to the schism, it seems, and no hope of joining a current edition for the foreseeable future if you don't like the cut of 4E's jib.

No need for me to check out the 5E books now. :(
 

log in or register to remove this ad

In before the thread gets closed. This is going to get ugly fast.

Anyways, I really hope they're not all ready putting the groundwork in for 5e. Considering how much it torpedoed things to have a new edition after 8 years, having a new edition even LESS than that isn't going to win them any friends, especially since they're putting work into recruiting new players with the Essentials.
 

I dunno, there's a chance.

It's happened often enough that an edition often will attempt to take cue's from earlier editions along with something said like, "we realize we lost something of what earlier editions did right, and we're trying to get some of [fill in the blank] back".

That doesn't need to be a devolution to get it "right".
 



But of course they are thinking about 5E, and you know what? They should. If the idea is for Dungeons & Dragons to be an evolving game that becomes better and better (whether or not this is the case, is beside the point), then the designers should be tallying what works and what doesn't, and thinking about how to improve the game.

My guess is that WotC has occasional semi-formal meetings on "What should 5E look like?" If they don't, they should, but I highly doubt that they don't.

This doesn't mean 5E is around the corner, just that it is likely being built as 4E is fleshed out.
 



Really?
No one has any idea about 5E yet, no matter what might be said in an interview, because it's not happening for years. I'd say there are a lot of factors that still have to be decided before we can say if 5E will be anything even remotely like previous editions. The notion that the next edition will be more evolutionary rather than revolutionary is something you always hear, because the designers who are working on 4E stuff actually like it...since they're right in the middle of designing it.

So there's no need for tears just quite yet...
 

I'd like to see that interview.

They've been learning a lot since the grand systematizing that was 3.0e, and I'm curious to see what they now think about the design decisions which went into 4e.

Cheers, -- N
 

Remove ads

Top