Jdvn1 said:
I don't mind either way, but I have noticed the game goes faster when the GM rolls.
The best way I've done of seeing it is the player posts his action and then includes the modifiers for the skills he wants (so the GM gets the modifier right) and then the GM narrarates and includes the result of the roll.
I would second the "game goes faster with GM rolls" part. I believe that is absolutely true. In the games I run - assuming everyone posts daily - I can often get through two full rounds of combat in a single day ... always at least one full round though.
If the DM is to rol for us, as far as making sure the rolls are done correctly here is what I would suggest as an example using Flitterdust's actual stats. These are very similar to what Jdvn1 has already posted, so it shouldn't surprise anyone with anything new:
Completely made-up example:
---------
Flitterdust notices the strange dragon over on the side of the valley. Flitterdust also notices how the dragon seems to be eyeing them suspiciously. He flutters up to about 30 feet from the dragon and lands, bowing as he lands. "Pardon me, esteemed dragon. I can't help but notice that you happen to be wary of my friends and myself. Is there anything that I can say or do to assure you that we mean to bring you absolutely no harm? In fact, we would love to speak to you if you would have our greeting."
[Sblock]Using Diplomacy to ensure the dragon is as friendly as possible. Diplomacy: +35[/Sblock]
-------
Or, if the DMs would want it, the Sblock could read:
[Sblock]Using Diplomacy to ensure the dragon is as friendly as possible. Diplomacy: +35 {+7(mod)+20(ranks)+8(Synergy:Bluff,Knowledge,SenseMotive and Feat:Negotiator)}[/Sblock]
The extra info added is easily enough done from my perspective, although not needed if the DM doesn't want it.
I also like what Wrahn says in that if we don't do the rolling, it may be easier for the DM to take our action declarations and put them together in a nice, neat, and quite easily read post. I have founf that to be true in my example as well.
In the end, though, I'll do whatever gets decided. Not a major issue, just wanted to make sure.