D&D General Greyhawk: Snarf's Guide to Ready-Made Campaign Themes!

MGibster

Legend
In a fit of desperation I purchased the 1983 Greyhawk TSR set from Drivethru RPG. This is the first time I'm reading this product as I never owned it nor did I know anyone who owned it. I haven't completed reading it yet, but so far it's a pretty good product as it has what I'm looking for in a setting.

There's a chapter devoted to trees. i.e. What kinds of trees are common in the northern, central, and southern Flanaess. They don't waste our time explaining what an elm tree but they do go over fictional trees like bronzewoods, galdas, and others. I suppose it's a small thing, but what I like about settings is when they have little details like this and I can think of ways to add them to adventures. It helps make the world feel a little more real.

Let's talk about astringent. One of the things I credited my love of AD&D (and other RPGs) is how much they helped me with my vocabulary. I knew what obfuscate meant when I was 15 because of Vampire and I can't count the number of words I added to my vocabulary because of AD&D. The fruit of the galda is slightly astringent, salty and nutritious. How many RPGs use the word astringent today?

So I plan on pitching a Greyhawk game to my group because we're at a loggerhead on what we should play. Some people want Fallout while others do not. Some are amenable to Deadlands but others are not. Only one of them wants to play Cyberpunk. I tried to pitch Pirate Borg but one person put the kibosh on that immediately. I think everyone likes D&D though.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Parmandur

Book-Friend, he/him
In a fit of desperation I purchased the 1983 Greyhawk TSR set from Drivethru RPG. This is the first time I'm reading this product as I never owned it nor did I know anyone who owned it. I haven't completed reading it yet, but so far it's a pretty good product as it has what I'm looking for in a setting.

There's a chapter devoted to trees. i.e. What kinds of trees are common in the northern, central, and southern Flanaess. They don't waste our time explaining what an elm tree but they do go over fictional trees like bronzewoods, galdas, and others. I suppose it's a small thing, but what I like about settings is when they have little details like this and I can think of ways to add them to adventures. It helps make the world feel a little more real.

Let's talk about astringent. One of the things I credited my love of AD&D (and other RPGs) is how much they helped me with my vocabulary. I knew what obfuscate meant when I was 15 because of Vampire and I can't count the number of words I added to my vocabulary because of AD&D. The fruit of the galda is slightly astringent, salty and nutritious. How many RPGs use the word astringent today?

So I plan on pitching a Greyhawk game to my group because we're at a loggerhead on what we should play. Some people want Fallout while others do not. Some are amenable to Deadlands but others are not. Only one of them wants to play Cyberpunk. I tried to pitch Pirate Borg but one person put the kibosh on that immediately. I think everyone likes D&D though.
One of the really cool things about it is that it is also pretty close to purely edition neutral, other than the wandering Monster tables and the NPC and god stats, and those aren't too big. Pretty much useful for any version of D&D.
 




Voadam

Legend
The The City of Greyhawk for 2nd edition worth the price of admission?
It is pretty good and I got a lot of good use out of it when my 1e Greyhawk group went to Greyhawk but be aware it is 2e and not Gygax so the flavor is more than a bit different from the 1e boxed set and Gygax's writing.

It is before the Greyhawk Wars so the 2e metaplot had not yet set in for the materials.

Alternatively you could use anything Lankhmar and change some names and it would work basically as well. Greyhawk was basically Gygax's D&D version of Lankhmar as a fantasy Chicago with organized crime and wizards instead of fantasy New York aspect as Lankhmar was Lieber's fantasy novel version of New York with organized crime and wizards. :)
 

AdmundfortGeographer

Getting lost in fantasy maps
The The City of Greyhawk for 2nd edition worth the price of admission?
Hot take: I keep hearing other long time fans rave about it. But there was little about it I liked, and most of it made me regret it, but I bought it from the clearance shelf cheap. Only after my completist collector impulse kicked in did I feel lucky to have acquired it. I’ve never gone back to it a single time, it just felt bland.

However, I do far prefer the Greyhawk city and region content in The Adventure Begins much more than the boxed set. However I’m a sucker for how the right art can make setting material land with me. And the art in tAB does it for me much more than the City of Greyhawk box. Kinda like how the art of Ruins of Symbaroun or Brom’s Dark Sun art just pull me in.
 
Last edited:

grodog

Hero
The The City of Greyhawk for 2nd edition worth the price of admission?

I was never a big fan of this set either. It didn’t feel like Greyhawk to me—far more RenFaire than gritty. It certainly didn’t match the style or tone from Gygax’s Gord stories and novels. Those richly detail the city, and are summarized by Krista Siren at The Greyhawk Lands - Greyhawk Online

Hot take: I’ve never gone back to it a single time, it just felt bland.

A great summation!

However, I do far prefer the Greyhawk city and region content in The Adventure Begin much more than the boxed set.

Agreed: I prefer the version of the city from tAB, using the maps and articles from Denis Tetreault and Erk Mona, liberally homebrewed and pulled from Gygax’s Gord tales.

Allan.
 


AdmundfortGeographer

Getting lost in fantasy maps
I was never a big fan of this set either. It didn’t feel like Greyhawk to me—far more RenFaire than gritty. It certainly didn’t match the style or tone from Gygax’s Gord stories and novels.
Huh, I really like that description as RenFaire. So accurate once you read through. That same tone seemed common through some other early 2e-era Greyhawk like Castle Hart.
 

Remove ads

Top