Heirmund helps a bewildered Redithidoor to his feet and guides Red around the corner, to find himself facing a surprisingly young and attractive half-elven female, wearing a chain helm and shirt. Beside her stands a man wearing a battered, worn breastplate, and behind them stand Garon, awkwardly wielding a home-made club, and another guardsman. They hide their shock at the sight of your condition with varying degrees of success--but it is obvious for each of them.
Jair examines the three fallen foes, and administers a Cure Minor Wounds to one of them. The other mugger is conscious, breathing shallowly, and apparently unharmed--but Jair finds that Ren has died of his wounds. Meanwhile, the rest of you guard the three other surviving prisoners. The relief in the air, released from the tension of just a few moments ago, is almost visible.
As Heirmund hands over his daggers to Felosial, he sees Redithidoor begin to run his hands through his hair, and then stop in distaste. "Ummm...hi Fel. Don't worry, I'm pretty sure these guys are all friends." He looks back towards the rest of you, his eyes lingering upon Ren and the muggers. "Some of them anyways. Uh, I think...?"
A rough voice calls out, "Need any help, Fel?" You can dimly make out a dwarf holding a rather large warhammer at the ready. Felosial calls out "No. Go back to sleep. Thanks Rurik." The dwarf--who you recognize now as the local blacksmith--eyes you all suspiciously, but only shrugs and turns back towards his nearby home, accross the main road. "You got it. Things change though, you just holler."
With this less-than-spectacular beginning, Felosial decides to take you all back to her constabulary, ordering Ben and Lou to take the two bodies--which they drag ignomiously along the muddy road. Garon says "Well, Fel, these guys did make words like they were gonna help Red. I just figgered they was acting, y'know? Trying to put me at my ease. --No offense."
Redithidoor scratches his head, forgetting his filthy condition for a moment. "Yeah. You know? Last thing I remember was crying for help, and then that big brute Ren stuck his sword in me! Yeah, they really did save me. These guys, I mean. Not Ren's gang." Felosial shakes her head, hiding a smile, and says "Red, I'm certain of it." She even allows you to keep your weapons as you walk down the muddy road.
The muggers are grim and quiet--except for Webster, who keeps up a nearly-constant stream of pleas for mercy, claiming he's only a petty thief, and he had no part in the violence. "These guys can vouch for me! I didn't fight, I swear! Look! Look at this! This is my puke! I don't wanna die!"
Felosial locks the muggers in the the stone building's single cage-like cell, and then turns to you. "All right, guys. What did Red do this time?"