Keen stacking


log in or register to remove this ad

Cool, 'cause I was just waiting for you to begin arguing that the Earth is truly flat, even though there is evidence that states otherwise, the mere fact that you say it is flat must make it so.

Argumentum ad hominem.
 



Kraedin said:
Is a change to a threat range a positive modifier to a die roll? No. Therefore, it cannot be a bonus, per the definition of the term.

You just don't get it.

The bonus to natural AC from Tenser's Transformation is not a die roll either, yet it is specifically labeled as a bonus. Here's another one...Bite of the Werebear gives a solid +16 bonus to your Strength score (got that confused with Tenser's), but according to you, that is not a bonus.
 
Last edited:

I don't write the rules, I just quote them.

(Here's a little secret: I've been waiting for days for bonuses to come up, just so I could use that absurd quote from the glossary. Now I'm waiting for someone to mention a fireball dealing damage, just so I can inform them that a fireball cannot deal damage, per the defenition of the term.)
 
Last edited:

Kraedin said:
I don't write the rules, I just quote them.

So, what you're saying is that you aren't actually willing to hold a discussion. You simply wish to copy text from a book and claim that you are correct while ignoring all evidence to the contrary, no matter what.

Dude, why the hell are you even here?
 


Kraedin said:


Is a change to a threat range a positive modifier to a die roll? No. Therefore, it cannot be a bonus, per the definition of the term.
You're using the wrong defination. The real defination of bonus is DMG 177, Chart 8-1. But even there the term isn't fully defined, anyway. (Mostly because, I think, some issues with stacking non nemueric bonuses, like speed bonuses and, had not yet been noticed. (For instance, there's a mention of Expedious Retreat(PH 202) providing an enhancemnt bonus to movement speed, even though according to that chart enhancement is limited to Weapons, Armor, and ability scores.)
 


Pets & Sidekicks

Remove ads

Top