I don't care how you split up items, but I would prefer one post in a thread that summarizes the total split up of the items. i.e. Raner gets this, Craven gets that, etc. Any items not being utilized could be assigned to a person for carrying purposes.
Whoever is in charge of splitting up the items could then edit that post as needed.
This will also help me in knowing how much of the loot was eaten by the monster the next time a monster swallows a character whole.
It might make sense to put that post in a Rogues Gallery thread, and then just update it like a character sheet. i.e. a treasure split post.