Orb of Force vs Antimagic Field

[KarinsDad]

I believe that it makes sense for the various other orb spells to be conjuration (creation) spells, conjuring actual acid, fire, etc.. But it doesn't make sense for "magical force" to not need to be held by magic.

Why does it make sense for sound to be held together in a globe without magic?

As for the others, doesn't acid spill all over the place if not held together by magic? Doesn't fire dissipate? Doesn't electricity ground?

Does a "globe" of any of these make sense without magic to sustain it?

 

[Thanee]

As far as I can tell, orb of force is now an Evocation, SR: yes spell. We will probably see it listed as such in the Spell Compendium.

From someone who has looked into the book already:
"As for the orb spells, it looks like they are exact copies of the CA versions (no SR, Conjurations, and effects)."

Bye
Thanee