Back when we would have time in life to play poker and make pina coladas, we finally settled on banana Cruzan, vanilla or coconut Bacardi, ice, vanilla ice cream, and Bacardi frozen pina colada mix. The hardest part at the time was finding an affordable home blender that would obliterate the ice well. None of us knew anything about rum, so would not be surprised if there are much better choices out there.
Last edited: