EzekielRaiden
Follower of the Way
Why?In other, blunter, words: you want me-as-DM to leave blank areas on the map (which by itself is great advice) so you-as-player can lobby to slide in things that wouldn't otherwise be in the game. That's...something not good.
I have genuinely no idea why you think this is "something not good".
You act like anyone who speaks up for their interests is somehow a subversive saboteur. Why? Isn't that exactly as antagonistic as acting like a GM who has preferences about their world is a vicious tyrant?
You basically ignored every single part of the purely hypothetical thing I was constructing, so I'm not really sure why I shouldn't do the same to you. It's really quite annoying to do that, I'll note. It makes it sound like you have no interest in actually discussing things, and instead just want to loudly berate me for having tastes and preferences you don't share.The setting as it is works just fine for the rest of us, why should it suddenly have to change just to support one player?
Never mind that in the specific case of bringing in a heretofore unknown PC species, if that species is thenceforth to be playable by anyone I then have to do a whole lot of work incorporating it into my rules. And if it's a unique one-off character I don't have to do all that work; but the player's hosed when it dies.