Rate Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince

[buzzard]

Only gave it a seven because there were some changes from the book that were unnecessary and I think an 8 requires a pretty darned good film. I enjoyed it, and I though they did pretty well given the limitations of the medium and what was in the book. I believe the important stuff was covered quite adequately, and I'll happily buy it for my collection when it comes to disc.

Honestly, I expected a much more harsh review around here.

 

[3dfan]

I still doubt 7 or 8 - because as for me was the best of the series but definitely not as good as the book