The "I Didn't Comment in Another Thread" Thread

[RealAlHazred]

You have claimed that "the crunchiest system" is Hero System, and I'm with you so far. But your next sentence claims that Pathfinder 2nd edition is "crunch-light," which tells me you don't actually understand what the word "crunchy" means.

 

[trappedslider]

You have claimed that "the crunchiest system" is Hero System, and I'm with you so far. But your next sentence claims that Pathfinder 2nd edition is "crunch-light," which tells me you don't actually understand what the word "crunchy" means.

Out of all the systems I have looked at GRUPS has to have the most crunch along with a few awesome flavor books (IW)

 

[Mad_Jack]

I remember the long hair thing; it was like that in my town, too, and like so many punkers I started off a metal head. Even with the jacket, I caught so much flack for the long hair.

It wasn't the length of the hair in my town (at least among people our own age) so much as the styling - long straight hair was metal, lol... But if you had big floofy hair like Bon Jovi and weren't one of the rock/metal crowd, chances were you'd end up getting crap for being a prettyboy.

 

[Mad_Jack]

But your next sentence claims that Pathfinder 2nd edition is "crunch-light," which tells me you don't actually understand what the word "crunchy" means.

I wouldn't describe any D20 system as "crunch-light", not even 5E...

 

[Mannahnin]

Out of all the systems I have looked at GRUPS has to have the most crunch along with a few awesome flavor books (IW)

GURPS is basically simplified Hero System in a lot of ways, as I recall.

 

[Cadence]

"I mean, this thing about humans, dwarves, elves, and halflings doesn't fit with anything in the literature really*. Gygax just made it up, it's just a D&Dism.""

"* Yeah what, one author?"

 

[payn]

You have claimed that "the crunchiest system" is Hero System, and I'm with you so far. But your next sentence claims that Pathfinder 2nd edition is "crunch-light," which tells me you don't actually understand what the word "crunchy" means.

I think because the system is designed so tightly, it makes the crunch easier to grok and use than systems of the past. It certainly does not make PF2 crunch lite tho!

 

[Snarf Zagyg]

You know, I don't think it's worked before.

But this time .... this time ... I know that if we just keep explaining to each other why we do, or don't, like a particular edition ... this time it will stick.

 

[dragoner]

If we are still doing videos, my opinion on systems ...

 

[RealAlHazred]

This is a gaming forum. "Don't Doowutchyalike / Doowutilike" would be more appropriate, no?