The mandalorian [Spoilers]

[doctorbadwolf]

She left the Jedi Order!

Her taking levels in Jedi Master would be no different to her taking levels in Sith Lord.

There is a RP prerequisite that you be a member of that Force tradition and meet the RP requirements (for Jedi Master, this generally entails training a Padawan to Knight level, and being admitted to the Council).

Shes left the order, renounced the Jedi, has never taken a Padawan to Knight lecel and was never on the Council.

It’s a skill set.

 

[doctorbadwolf]

Scouts usually good for evasion. Yay look at my block and defelect.

Look at my thermal detonator, autofire and shotgun.

Scout Jedi

Fml.

Quite a few soldier talents apply to lightsabers think I just stopped using block and deflect due to talent tax.

Scouts get Shake It Off, and more skills. Scout1/SoldierX is objectively better than straight soldier.

 

[Maxperson]

She left the Jedi Order!

Her taking levels in Jedi Master would be no different to her taking levels in Sith Lord.

There is a RP prerequisite that you be a member of that Force tradition and meet the RP requirements (for Jedi Master, this generally entails training a Padawan to Knight level, and being admitted to the Council).

Shes left the order, renounced the Jedi, has never taken a Padawan to Knight lecel and was never on the Council.

So what. She received the training and is on the path, regardless of titles which have nothing whatsoever to do with the force path being walked. All she has to do is keep walking down that same path regardless of what the Council wants and she will become a Jedi Master in all but literally name. Same skills. Same abilities. Same levels.

 

[Maxperson]

There are other Force users with those skills and talents. Force Adepts and Force Deiciples. Neither require you to be a member of the Jedi Order, and acceptance onto the Council or the training of a Padawan to Knighthood

If you ask Ashoka if shes a Jedi Master, she would say No.

And yet she would have the same abilities and levels, regardless of whether she says she has the title or not.

 

[Zardnaar]

So what. She received the training and is on the path, regardless of titles which have nothing whatsoever to do with the force path being walked. All she has to do is keep walking down that same path regardless of what the Council wants and she will become a Jedi Master in all but literally name. Same skills. Same abilities. Same levels.

In game turns no in overall power yes.

The difference between Jedi 7/Jedi knight 5, Jedi master 2 vs jedi 7, Jedi knight 7 is marginal.

That's the discussion we were having about game rules.

A scout 1, soldier 6, force adept 5, force disciple 2 can easily fight a Jedi of equivilent level. Not quite as accurate, better will save outright immune to mind stuff.

In game if you're force sensitive force talents can be taken with any class talents.

So the only real advantage a Jedi has is specific Jedi Talents.

Ahsoka could be Jedi 7, Jedi Knight 2, Scout 5 and not miss out on much.

 

[trappedslider]

Has anyone thought to look at Fantasy Flight Games instead of the old WotC books?

 

[Zardnaar]

Has anyone thought to look at Fantasy Flight Games instead of the old WotC books?

That wasn't the conversation though.

Not familiar with FFG, own D6 and SWSE so didn't feel like buying a 3rd game I barely get to play.

More people probably vaguely familiar with d20 as well.

 

[Gradine]

Poll: what makes this thread more insufferable to read? Immaculata's endless baiting thread-crapping, or the arguing over a character's theoretical TTRPG stats?

 

[Zardnaar]

Good video about latest episode and what the show is doing right.


Not salty or anything mostly about attachments.

 

[Imaculata]

Poll: what makes this thread more insufferable to read? Immaculata's endless baiting thread-crapping, or the arguing over a character's theoretical TTRPG stats?

This is a discussion thread about the show. Why does all discussion about it have to be positive? If you think I'm baiting, then you seem to be suggesting I don't actually mean the things I say about the show, and you would be wrong. I'm honest about the things I think the show does right, but also about the things that I find lacking about it. I think that should be open to discussion. I didn't see a disclaimer at the top of this thread that said that you have to like every aspect of the show.

I am a huge and proud Star Wars fan/nerd and I have quite a large collection of Star Wars toys to show for it. And yet, people on this forum know that I also strongly disliked Rogue One, a movie that every Star Wars fan seems to praise to high heavens. But just because I am a huge fan of the franchise, does not mean I leave my brain at the door whenever they toss out another product.

Also, people can speculate about the theoretical RPG stats of characters on the show all they want. After all, character development in this show does feel a lot like a videogame, where a character gets a new armor or jetpack and levels up every few episodes, instead of... you know... actual character development.