The mandalorian [Spoilers]

[Flamestrike]

Who is the chosen one? Last update we got it wasn't Anakin.

He was the chosen one. He destroyed the Sith (temporarily) and brought balance to the Force.

Unfortunately balance meant 1 Jedi (Luke) and 1 Sith (reborn Sidious).

 

[Enevhar Aldarion]

Who is the chosen one? Last update we got it wasn't Anakin.

Luke became the Chosen One, as per the Rebels episode "Twin Suns" where Obi-wan finally kills Maul. Maul asked him if he was protecting the Chosen One and he said yes.

 

[Zardnaar]

Luke became the Chosen One, as per the Rebels episode "Twin Suns" where Obi-wan finally kills Maul. Maul asked him if he was protecting the Chosen One and he said yes.

Yeah that's what I was referring. That was the last update.

 

[Maxperson]

He was the chosen one. He destroyed the Sith (temporarily) and brought balance to the Force.

Unfortunately balance meant 1 Jedi (Luke) and 1 Sith (reborn Sidious).

The balance happened before that. Two Jedi, Yoda and Obi-Wan and two Sith, Vader and The Emperor.

 

[Levistus's_Leviathan]

The balance happened before that. Two Jedi, Yoda and Obi-Wan and two Sith, Vader and The Emperor.

And then Rise of Skywalker (and Last Jedi) screwed up that balance with 1 Jedi (Rey), 1 Force-Sensitive Slave-Kid, and no Sith.

 

[doctorbadwolf]

Neither does Ahsoka she left before they could teach her.

It's like university, need to stay longer to get masters/phd.

don't be ridiculous. There is a huge difference, and nothing in the lore suggests that you need a teacher to go from knight to master.

The Jedi Master class in the game is a set of mechanics built to describe people who have mastered the the arts of force use and knowledge in the ideological tradition of the Jedi.

The title of Jedi Master could easily be given to someone who doesn't even have the knoweldge to deserve it, but they wouldn't have levels of the PrC. Likewise, someone who has continued their study in exile, but whose foundational instruction is from the Jedi, could take levels of Jedi Master.

 

[doctorbadwolf]

And then Rise of Skywalker (and Last Jedi) screwed up that balance with 1 Jedi (Rey), 1 Force-Sensitive Slave-Kid, and no Sith.

No, the balance was never numerical. Balance is the defeat of the dark side. The dark side is an imbalance in the force.

 

[doctorbadwolf]

And Ashoka has no connection to the knowledge of a Jedi Master. She is not a member of the Jedi tradition and does not adhere to the Jedi Code, so she cant take levels in Jedi Master!

From the rules:



She is not a member of the Jedi Order. Her journey in the Jedi tradition from Padawan Learner ended when she left the order after being offered the rank of Knight. She never reached the 'final destination' of Jedi Master.



She hasnt done this either; either be a Knight or train a Padawan to Knighthood.

And most importantly:



Ashoka Tano does not adhere to the Jedi Code. She is no longer a member of the Jedi force tradition, and as such she cannot become a Jedi Master, any more than she could become a Sith Lord.

None of that actually precludes her taking levels in the Jedi Master PrC.

All it precludes is her taking the title. That's it.

 

[Levistus's_Leviathan]

Neither does Ahsoka she left before they could teach her.

It's like university, need to stay longer to get masters/phd.

There's a difference between being able/trained to do something and being allowed to do something. Ahsoka could be capable/trained for being a Jedi Knight/Master/(whatever you were arguing about), even if the Council didn't approve of it.

 

[doctorbadwolf]

There's a difference between being able/trained to do something and being allowed to do something. Ahsoka could be capable/trained for being a Jedi Knight/Master/(whatever you were arguing about), even if the Council didn't approve of it.

exactly.