The mandalorian [Spoilers]

[Zardnaar]

No, they haven’t. Non-Jedi/Sith, sure. Not grey Jedi.

Ahsokas basically a grey Jedi.

There's 3 ways you can interpret a grey Jedi though so go figure.

 

[pukunui]

And the EU is wholly irrelevant. I don’t buy that Disney is going with the terrible EU concept of a dualistic force. They seem, to me, to be referencing the idea as a thing some people in the world believe, not as a thing that is actually true.

I respectfully disagree. Mortis was under George's watch, but Disney has brought the family back via Rebels, appearing in an ancient mural on the base of an ancient Jedi temple. It's a "magical" mural, and Ezra and Sabine are able to activate a portal to the "World Beyond Worlds" by interacting with the mural.

Also, in ep 7, we have Leia quoting Luke's famous "There's still good in him" line in reference to her son but she says "light" instead of "good". No one in the movies before that had ever referred to light. There was only ever "the Force", "good" and "the dark side".

In ep 8, when Luke is teaching Rey about the Force, they talk about how it the Force is a balance between life and death, peace and violence, etc ... e.g. a balance between light and dark.

 

[Morrus]

Book series, I can post them up if you want. They're ok, previous series was a lot better.

They were really going into the origins of the Jedi, the force and ancient past towards the end of legends. We'll see how much Tython follows Legends Tython.

Why don't you start a "Zaardnaar Star Wars EU" thread? Then those interested in that topic can talk to you about it there. Didn't I start one for you once because every Star Wars thread was turning into the Zaardnaar EU thread?

 

[Zardnaar]

Why don't you start a "Zaardnaar Star Wars EU" thread? Then those interested in that topic can talk to you about it there. Didn't I start one for you once because every Star Wars thread was turning into the Zaardnaar EU thread?

They've since recanonized several things from it which was what I referenced.

The Rise of Skywalker movie book.

And Rebels, Clone Wars, And Mandalorian.

If you paid attention perhaps you would know this it's back in canon.

See previous comment on how well Tython matches up. World Between World was legends Rebels reused it.

Canon

Tython

Tython was a terrestrial planet located in Deep Core's Tython system that played a pivotal role in the history of the Jedi Order. A verdant world that was incredibly rich in the Force, Tython was eventually abandoned when the ever-changing hyperlanes in the region drifted away from the planet...

starwars.fandom.com

World Between Worlds

 

[pukunui]

Why don't you start a "Zaardnaar Star Wars EU" thread? Then those interested in that topic can talk to you about it there. Didn't I start one for you once because every Star Wars thread was turning into the Zaardnaar EU thread?

Maybe @Zardnaar and @Flamestrike could have their own SWSE stats argument thread too?

 

[Morrus]

They've since recanonized several things from it which was what I referenced.

The Rise of Skywalker movie book.

And Rebels, Clone Wars, And Mandalorian.

If you paid attention perhaps you would know this it's back in canon.

See previous comment on how well Tython matches up. World Between World was legends Rebels reused it.

Canon

Tython

Tython was a terrestrial planet located in Deep Core's Tython system that played a pivotal role in the history of the Jedi Order. A verdant world that was incredibly rich in the Force, Tython was eventually abandoned when the ever-changing hyperlanes in the region drifted away from the planet...

starwars.fandom.com

World Between Worlds

Dude, nobody has the desire or capacity to ‘pay attention’ (is the snark needed?) to all the Star Wars cartoons, games, and novels that you do. But to clarify: this is a thread for those who want to discuss The Mandalorian, which you haven’t been talking about for several pages now. You do this every time. It really frustrating.

 

[Zardnaar]

Dude, nobody has the desire or capacity to ‘pay attention’ (is the snark needed?) to all the Star Wars cartoons, games, and novels that you do. But to clarify: this is a thread for those who want to discuss The Mandalorian, which you haven’t been talking about for several pages now. You do this every time. It really frustrating.

Apologies there's a certain amount of crossover from the clone wars thread. Some of the character arcs cross two or three shows.

 

[doctorbadwolf]

Ahsokas basically a grey Jedi.

There's 3 ways you can interpret a grey Jedi though so go figure.

Grey in the sense of “balancing” light and dark is not a thing, and Ahsoka certainly isn’t anything close to it even if it were. She is Light 100%, she just isn’t Jedi.

I respectfully disagree. Mortis was under George's watch, but Disney has brought the family back via Rebels, appearing in an ancient mural on the base of an ancient Jedi temple. It's a "magical" mural, and Ezra and Sabine are able to activate a portal to the "World Beyond Worlds" by interacting with the mural.

Also, in ep 7, we have Leia quoting Luke's famous "There's still good in him" line in reference to her son but she says "light" instead of "good". No one in the movies before that had ever referred to light. There was only ever "the Force", "good" and "the dark side".

In ep 8, when Luke is teaching Rey about the Force, they talk about how it the Force is a balance between life and death, peace and violence, etc ... e.g. a balance between light and dark.

You can interpret death and violence as the dark side, but I am gonna disagree. Those are part of nature. The dark side isn’t.

 

[Zardnaar]

Grey in the sense of “balancing” light and dark is not a thing, and Ahsoka certainly isn’t anything close to it even if it were. She is Light 100%, she just isn’t Jedi.

You can interpret death and violence as the dark side, but I am gonna disagree. Those are part of nature. The dark side isn’t.

We'll have to wait and see with Ahsoka.

She's a Jedi in the sense she knows her way around a lightsaber. Doesn't consider herself one. I suspect this is also a way around the LujeLeia being the only ones in that time frame when Yoda and Obiwan were talking.

Even then it's a bit open ended.

 

[trappedslider]

Apologies there's a certain amount of crossover from the clone wars thread. Some of the character arcs cross two or three shows.

Could just leave it with this is tied into X instead of going all expliany about X or footnote see blah blah blah.....