Hussar
Legend
Then answer my question ... which type are their superiority dice? They don't operate mechanically on any of those paradigms... But yeah keep telling yourself it's presentation..
EDIT: Even Action Surge replenishes on a long or short rest... so is it daily? No... because it will replenish on a short rest... is it an encounter? No... because it can recharge on a long rest... is it at-will? Nope... so you tell me how again is this AEDU?
Umm, you do realise that Encounter Power do recharge on both a short and long rest in 4e too right?
Wait what... your complaint is that in 5e he's versatile enough that mid-attack the fighter can switch from doing an AoE attack to focused damage if he chooses... He's supposed to be a master of combat why is that a bad thing again? I don't even know what to say here... that's been our point all along, the versatility and flexibility inherent in 5e... I don't have power that forces me to act in an exact way with an exact outcome... instead it's based on how I choose to use it in play and in the moment...
Read more: http://www.enworld.org/forum/showthread.php?408712-What-are-the-Roles-now/page44#ixzz3PzM7PoSZ
No, my complaint is that he's not a CONTROLLER. Stop moving the goalposts. Controllers cannot do what a fighter can do. Thus, a fighter is not a controller. Also note, that the fighter STILL can only do this burst attack, against 4, maybe 5 targets, ONCE per short rest. Regardless of whether he has a reach weapon or not.
Now you've made a very weak controller - a reach of ten feet that, regardless of how many enemies he can actually reach, can only attack a limited number of them. Again, not a controller.