I've got a shoebox full of the figures-Warduke, Kalek, Titan, Mandoom, Melf, and many more. I've also got a bunch of the hard rubber monster figures-troll, ogre, lich, men at arms, etc.
Many of my old 1e modules have the puffy stickers stuck on the covers of them. Some of the stickers are the same characters as the figures, but some I never saw elsewhere-Foxfingers the thief? :\
A couple of the old early 1980s Mail Order Hobby Shop catalogs with stuff circled on every page that I never got the money to purchase.
3 of the 4 Monster Cards sets.
And somewhere in storage, I've got a couple of the candy boxes. There is probably more stuff that I'm forgetting as well, since a lot of that stuff has been in boxes in my Moms attic for years. Maybe on my next trip to NY I'll see if I can find it.
And my biggest treasure-a folder with the notes from my first campaign when I was 10 years old. "The New Olympus Quest" is written in big letters across the front, and a map of some mountains, a couple rivers, and 2 castles is drawn below the title. It's really not much more than a couple of Basic and 1e adventures strung together and a bunch of old character sheets, but it's all still there.
