What Licensed RPG Do You Wish Existed But Doesn't?

RareBreed

Explorer
Having read and played the game, I'm gonna have to disagree hard here.
Disclaimer, I only read, and did not play the game.

That being said, I generally don't like any kind of "class" based game, and IMHO, the playbooks are a lot like classes as they determine what moves you get.

The balancing mechanic was interesting and does suit the game world to some degree, but I still feel like the playbooks are a bit too constraining. Since this was my first PbtA game, I didn't know what to expect, but it just didn't really hook me in. YMMV of course
 

log in or register to remove this ad


Aldarc

Legend
Disclaimer, I only read, and did not play the game.

That being said, I generally don't like any kind of "class" based game, and IMHO, the playbooks are a lot like classes as they determine what moves you get.

The balancing mechanic was interesting and does suit the game world to some degree, but I still feel like the playbooks are a bit too constraining. Since this was my first PbtA game, I didn't know what to expect, but it just didn't really hook me in. YMMV of course
If you don't like classes or playbooks, then I could definitely see how you would bounce off Avatar Legends. Tastes obviously vary.
 

I'm watching Lockwood and Co on Netflix now and it would be a solid setting.
I also really liked the worldbuilding in Jupiter Ascending, even if the film itself is mediocre. Great visuals.
 

RareBreed

Explorer
If you don't like classes or playbooks, then I could definitely see how you would bounce off Avatar Legends. Tastes obviously vary.
If nothing else, it has some lore that I wasn't aware of :) Made me want to go and buy the graphic novels that I didn't even know existed.

This reminds me, I need to send an email to Magpie...the distributor did a crappy job delivering, and my lenticular covers and Wang Shi Tong guides all got some pretty badly dented corners. Apparently I'm not the only one. A lot of Kickstarter folks were complaining.
 

Jer

Legend
Supporter
I'm watching Lockwood and Co on Netflix now and it would be a solid setting.
It's a fun show - I was just talking to my kid about how we'd adapt it. Probably a Gumshoe game or Monster of the Week rather than D&D was where we've settled so far.

I also really liked the worldbuilding in Jupiter Ascending, even if the film itself is mediocre. Great visuals.
Jupiter Ascending actually has the makings of a great campy film moderately ruined by having creators who can't edit their own work being at a stage in their careers where nobody was willing to make them edit it or edit it for them. It feels like a film where they wrote a trilogy and then were told to make a single movie and rather than rewrite the first film to make it standalone they smashed all three movies together instead.

That said - I've already ripped off Jupiter Ascending worldbuilding stuff for a number of games myself. And the next time I run Spelljammer I'll probably do it again :)
 

It's a fun show - I was just talking to my kid about how we'd adapt it. Probably a Gumshoe game or Monster of the Week rather than D&D was where we've settled so far.


Jupiter Ascending actually has the makings of a great campy film moderately ruined by having creators who can't edit their own work being at a stage in their careers where nobody was willing to make them edit it or edit it for them. It feels like a film where they wrote a trilogy and then were told to make a single movie and rather than rewrite the first film to make it standalone they smashed all three movies together instead.

That said - I've already ripped off Jupiter Ascending worldbuilding stuff for a number of games myself. And the next time I run Spelljammer I'll probably do it again :)
I'm a sucker for a sci-fi story that has an actual reason for why aliens would visit earth.
 





payn

Legend
Mass Effect. Please God, I need a Mass Effect RPG
tumblr_pomwslHGTX1xyem48o1_500.gif
 

Undrave

Hero
Pirates of the Caribbean, if you can get ship combat to work.

While the plots got wacky and Jack Sparrow gets on one’s nerves after a while, the ideas were generally pretty solid adventure hooks, and there’s more where that came from.
Which reminds me I was musing on Twitter on how it would probably be possible to make a Dread style game where you replace the Jenga tower with a Pop Up Pirate.
 


Mad_Jack

Hero
Malazan was mentioned up thread. Ironically it started as a GURPS game.

Simon R. Greens books, The Deathstalker series, Hawk and Fisher, or pretty much anything else. All are very gameable I think.

Another vote for Malazan as well.

SRG's books could definitely get their own rpg - the Nightside and Secret Histories books are definitely diverse and crazy enough to support their own game worlds, and I've been mining Hawk & Fisher for D&D stuff since I first read the books decades ago.

CLD: Collective Landing Detachment by Victor Milan might have enough meat on its bones to make for an interesting game if the world was a bit more fleshed out - it's basically the lovechild of Starship Troopers and WH40K - but would probably make an even better tabletop skirmish game.

The Thieftaker Chronicles series by D.B. Jackson is about a conjurer working as a thieftaker in immediately-pre-Revolutionary-War Boston. With a little fleshing out of the setting, you could have games of political intrigue, magic, soldiers, pirates, thieves...
 


Aldarc

Legend
The more I think about it, the angier I am that there is no ME ttrpg.
I would probably look at the AGE system, since it was first designed for Bioware's Dragon Age RPG and has expanded with a Modern AGE and the Expanse RPG. A lot of the pieces for a Mass Effect RPG are scattered among the different publications.
 




An Advertisement

Advertisement4

Top