Which is better Star Wars or Star Trek?

[jonesy]

Kirk would do it in one episode. Solo took three movies. Kirk wins!

But it was frickin Leia for Jebus' sake! That earns him bonus points.

 

[Starman]

But it was frickin Leia for Jebus' sake! That earns him bonus points.

Maybe, but Leia was tainted by contact with her, uh, brother, and Kirk would have seduced a few planets full of women by the end of three movies.

 

[sniffles]

pining for the fjords?

"Finland, Finland, Finland..."

Maybe this should have been a poll?

I like both for different reasons. Parts of Trek are better than parts of SW and vice-versa.
I'm nicely straddling the fence, aren't I?

 

[Lord Pendragon]

Both franchises are so expansive that I think it's impossible compare them fairly.

I could field an opinion on various individual pieces of the competing franchises. DS9 vs. The Phantom Menace. Or Enterprise vs. SW: Clone Wars.

But there is such a lack of uniformity in either of the two universes, that it seems preposterous to try and compare them at that level.

 

[Man in the Funny Hat]

If comparing just the original SW to any and/or ALL of Trek, SW wins comfortably. If comparing SW as an entire series to any/all Trek then Trek wins. SW suffers HORRIBLY the further along it gets and the Prequels are unmitigated dead weight.

 

[Starman]

"Star Wars or Star Trek. There is no middle ground."

 

[Silver Moon]

Splunge!

 

[Ranger REG]

anything is beter then the star trek:Enterprise crap that upn put out. heck even voyeger and DS9 was better then Enterprise.

Actually, I liked the fourth season of Enterprise, with the exception of the series finale episode.

 

[Goodsport]

Fjord!

Is the 'j' silent?


-G

 

[Goodsport]

No, Star Star

Jar Jar?


-G