The fireball spell through the editions

Scribble

First Post
Quasqueton said:
Looking at the specific text of the spells, I find the subtle changes the most interesting. The mentions of melting metals, the spelling of sulphur/sulfur, streak vs. pea-sized bead, the spelling of the spell (two words vs. one word). Much of the text in AD&D1, AD&D2, and D&D3 seemed to be copy and paste, so the subtle changes had to be intentionally made.

Quasqueton

I'm assuming the streak vrs Bead edit was to prevent people from confusing fireball with a ray effect? (or a line)
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Henry

Autoexreginated
In one old Dungeon adventure, I saw a fighter take out almost HALF of an entire warren of goblins in 5' x 5' corridors with one fireball from a necklace of missiles. He just ducked and took the damage, and the goblins just fried and died, whether they made their save or not. :) you think 33 10' cubes are brutal - how about 264!!?!?!!


I do miss the compression effect, but don't really miss the melting of metals, because I don't see why things like steel would melt, though lead and copper I think definitely would.
 

DethStryke

Explorer
I'm far more disappointed by the changes to Lightning Bolt than Fireball. :(

That melting point issue makes me realize that alot of the DMs I've played under don't really remember to count this in... When was the last time that your DM ruled that all the coin the monsters were carrying in little pouches on their belt were melted into small multi-colored balls of precious metal?
 

Scribble

First Post
DethStryke said:
I'm far more disappointed by the changes to Lightning Bolt than Fireball. :(

That melting point issue makes me realize that alot of the DMs I've played under don't really remember to count this in... When was the last time that your DM ruled that all the coin the monsters were carrying in little pouches on their belt were melted into small multi-colored balls of precious metal?

I once played a halfling cleric named Roofus. He got ambushed by a bunch of spiders that pulled him up into a tree. The party mage, in order to "save" roofus, blasted the whole tree with a Fire Ball... The DM ruled my chainmail melted and fused with my skin. Ouch.

But hey, it gave me a "natural" armor class! :p
 

lukelightning

First Post
Ah yes, the good old days of fireball expansion. That was my first lesson on how to find the volume of a sphere (my older brother had to explain how the 33000 number came from).

My magic-user was a friggin' terror in the dungeon; thankfully my DM was gracious enough to allow us to use the "open the door a crack...fireball in, slam the door and jump back" strategy.

We also had something called an "All-Dice Fireball" which was a special ability we got granted from some deity for killing a demon lord. An All-Dice Fireball was just that: A fireball that's damage is ALL THE DICE. No, not a d4 and a d6 and a d8, etc. No, not even all the d6's. It was ALL THE DICE IN THE HOUSE :eek: . We raided the yahtzee and monopoly games, scrounged up every die we could find.

*BOOM* then spend the next 15 minutes tallying up the damage....woo hoo, 343 points! Whaddaya mean pit fiends are immune to fire!?!?!? :confused:
 

lukelightning

First Post
DethStryke said:
When was the last time that your DM ruled that all the coin the monsters were carrying in little pouches on their belt were melted into small multi-colored balls of precious metal?

No big problem; all the gold melts into a blob so you don't need to worry about spilling coins.

I guess that's where all those electrum pieces came from: All the sp and gp melting together.
 

el-remmen

Moderator Emeritus
I still use 33,000 cubic foot fireballs.

Heck, and bouncing lightning bolts as well - if the bolt does not do enough damage to break through a barrier, it bounces back instead. :cool:
 

Henry

Autoexreginated
el-remmen said:
I still use 33,000 cubic foot fireballs.

Heck, and bouncing lightning bolts as well - if the bolt does not do enough damage to break through a barrier, it bounces back instead.

You, I like. :lol:
 


Sidekick

First Post
El-Remmen: you're my hero :cool:


Ahh yes the good old days of 2nd ed. When I could blow :):):):) up real good in a dungeon.

fireball was my friend.

I also really miss the bouncing lightning bolt. Once my DM had us fight a gold golem in a dungeon where lots of the walls were at strange angles. We didn't get it until the lightning bolts trap came into effect. The damn thing jumped about all over the place making us lose about 60% of the standing room.

Upside - when we killed the golem, it came time for trying to carry out all the treasure. We tallies up all the coins, adn then realised that the leg of the golem was worth more than then coins we could carry. So we left the coins & took the leg and gems.

The banker in town wal well surprised when we asked to exchange the leg for trade bars and gems. hehehe
 

Remove ads

Top