The Orville Season Two - Thoughts?

Morrus

Well, that was fun
Staff member
We also don't know much in universe about there FTL drives.

In Star Wars 30 hours could get you form one side on the galaxy to the other on a good hyperlane in something like the Falcon. It took 4 hours from Tatooine to Alderaan and the Falcon- 8 hour trip .5 hyperdrive. That is almost half way across the galaxy.

Exactly. In Star Wars, halfway across the galaxy isn’t remote. It’s a day trip. I’m Star Trek halfway across the galaxy is a journey of years, so the Delta Quadrant is indeed remote. In medieval times, India was remote; now it’s a few hours on a plane.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Dannyalcatraz

Schmoderator
Staff member
Supporter
I’m going to go an record as guessing that a “cycle” is going to be more akin to a day than anything else.

“Cycle”, to me, sounds like completing a repeating process back to its starting point. So in astronomical terms, that would be something like an orbit or a planetary rotation rather than a subdivision of a day. A planetary orbit- a.k.a. a day- or even just a lunar orbit- roughly a month, in our system- seems waaaay too long. What earth-centric (assumption, yes) interstellar organization would take a ship out of regular duty for (essentially) 2.25 years to possibly ressurrect a crewman, even one as exemplay as Isaac seemed to be?

OTOH, if a “cycle” is a day (one of Kaylon’s planetary rotations), unless it’s exceedingly odd, we’re talking less than months or years. 30 days travel A=>B seems pretty distant, regardless of scale.

And of course, since the Kaylons seem to want The Orville riding point on this mission for some reason, even if they have faster ships, they won’t be using them at full speed...on the way back, at least. So that’s 30 days/cycles back into Union territory.

It will be interesting to see why the officers (at least) were kept alive.
 
Last edited:


Zardnaar

Legend
I figure 30 days as well. They did it off camera. Back in the day it was a couple of weeks across the Atlantic, 3 months UK to NZ.

30 days cN happen in Star Wars as well at speed 2 hyper drive unexplored or lesser known routes.
 

Maxperson

Morkus from Orkus
It was within 30ish cycles of the Orville's location at the time, which wasn't Earth.

It couldn't have been that far away, though. They were communicating with Earth in real time. No delay. It seems really unlikely to me that they could go from instant communications to out of communications in 30 hours.
 

cbwjm

Seb-wejem
It couldn't have been that far away, though. They were communicating with Earth in real time. No delay. It seems really unlikely to me that they could go from instant communications to out of communications in 30 hours.
Star trek has subspace communication arrays to help facilitate communications. Maybe the Orville universe has something similar and there simply aren't any that far out of union space.
 

Maxperson

Morkus from Orkus
Star trek has subspace communication arrays to help facilitate communications. Maybe the Orville universe has something similar and there simply aren't any that far out of union space.

That's an idea, but I still think the simplest explanation is correct and it's 30ish days.
 


CapnZapp

Legend
It most certainly is not! We were told, very clearly, that the Orville would be *outside communication range*. The only way to get the information would be to send ships back and forth.

This being crucial, as there was no way for the Orville to warn the Union of what's happening...
You know I meant the technical information they hope to bring back from Kaylon in case of an alliance.

Whether Kaylon is too far away for a proper defense perimeter doesn't matter if what they offer you are cool upgrades.
 

Ryujin

Legend
You know I meant the technical information they hope to bring back from Kaylon in case of an alliance.

Whether Kaylon is too far away for a proper defense perimeter doesn't matter if what they offer you are cool upgrades.

And unfortunately the upgrades turned out to be of the Cybermen variety, without the brain saving part.
 

Remove ads

Top