Ruin Explorer
Legend
This wasn’t really a complaint about the show, these kind of details are just not covered (and really don’t need to be covered) in Star Trek, it’s just fun speculating about what things might look like that far in the future. Trying to actually imagine what it would be like to live in such times.
Menopause is not a factor of maximum longevity or even overall health. Women have a set number of eggs, and when they run out they run out. Now it’s possible in the future women have a procedure to great increase this number to off set menopause, or something like that. We could argue genetic adjustment as an option but we know that has been frowned upon at this. Or it’s possible that Beverly got extremely lucky (or unlucky from a point of view) that she got pregnant at such an age without intervention.
The note that they might not birth control at all is an interesting one, it would suggest that abortion has become the cultural norm this far in the future, which is certainly possible if hard to imagine based on our present, at least from an American perspective.
I mean, that's an outdated and extremely simplified and inaccurate view on the causes of menopause, one that is sometimes still repeated (like every outdated medical view), but doesn't hold up scientifically. To say it's "more complicated than that" would be putting it mildly - but to be very specific the "egg clock" idea has since been hard-demonstrated to be false - for example: Menopause reversal restores periods and produces fertile eggs - that would be 100% impossible if the egg clock idea was true, because you would be out. So it definitely isn't. It seems quite likely to me that the same treatments that keep humans so healthy they can routinely live to 120+ might well have similar effects, either intentionally or otherwise.
Re: "abortion", in very few places in the world is "morning after pill"-type stuff like I'm describing regarded as "abortion" in any meaningful sense. Even most Americans don't regard it that way (based on the last surveys I've seen - and younger people really, really didn't). It's just that the ones who do have deafeningly loud voices in the US for US-specific political reasons which don't apply in much of the world, and that certainly don't apply to a setting like Star Trek where science, reason, and compassion are centered.
Re: "abortion", in very few places in the world is "morning after pill"-type stuff like I'm describing regarded as "abortion" in any meaningful sense. Even most Americans don't regard it that way (based on the last surveys I've seen - and younger people really, really didn't). It's just that the ones who do have deafeningly loud voices in the US for US-specific political reasons which don't apply in much of the world, and that certainly don't apply to a setting like Star Trek where science, reason, and compassion are centered.
Also hahahahahaha I just read about the end of Picard S2 (which I couldn't get to) and omg I am laughing because of the phrase "a small Borg cooperative", not that it's dumb idea, just a very funny one.