Recent content by Philosopher

  1. Philosopher

    AD&D 1st Edition Books

    Those books all came out initially with the orange spine. It was the earlier books (except for the Fiend Folio) that got the redone covers, in order to give them the orange spine. I figure it's because they wanted them all to be easily recognizable on bookstore shelves.
  2. Philosopher

    Removed

    Correct. If power corrupts, then Iluvatar, Middle Earth's supreme being, would be more corrupt than Morgoth and Sauron put together.
  3. Philosopher

    Seeking advice on the Cloistered Cleric

    How about just having the cloistered cleric getting three of the deity's domains? In other words, replacing the Knowledge domain with another domain.
  4. Philosopher

    What's the current, in print, status of Castle Zagyg??

    I'd love a PDF too. Given that the license has been withdrawn, I'm not sure if even this would be available.
  5. Philosopher

    World of Greyhawk Folio - 30 years on

    In terms of utility, I prefer hexes all the way. As the Darlene map shows, aesthetics need not be sacrificed for this utility.
  6. Philosopher

    Pathfinder 1E Freeport Pathfinder Companion

    Check out the free hand fighter archetype in the Advanced Player's Guide. It's designed for fighting with a one-handed weapon while the other hand is free. It gains a dodge bonus to AC while wearing light armour. It also gets bonuses on using various combat maneuvers. Check it out here (scroll...
  7. Philosopher

    Eldritch Knights and prepared spellcasters

    Good question. This is the first time I've heard this point come up for Pathfinder. (Then again, I don't follow many threads on the Paizo boards too frequently.) It might be that they're not aware of the issue. Have you brought this up on the Paizo boards?
  8. Philosopher

    Eldritch Knights and prepared spellcasters

    I'm not disagreeing with your interpretation. All I did was make an offhand comment about the actual wording of the parenthetical condition. I didn't mean it as a point of discussion. The main point I had wanted to make was that the wording was poor. Also, that I don't like the rule.
  9. Philosopher

    Eldritch Knights and prepared spellcasters

    The if in question is making the statement conditional on spontaneous casters, not the benefits of gaining a spellcasting level. As you quoted, "spells known (if he is a spontaneous spellcaster)".
  10. Philosopher

    Eldritch Knights and prepared spellcasters

    Strictly speaking, gaining spells known if one is a spontaneous caster says nothing about prepared casters. You're interpreting it as if it said only if instead of just if. In any case, the wording is poor. This issue came up about prestige classes in general in 3.5. I've always given wizards...
  11. Philosopher

    Wanted: Female point of veiw

    Do you really see no difference between asking two specific women what they think about something, and asking a generic online crowd to come up with an overgeneralization about women?
  12. Philosopher

    Wanted: Female point of veiw

    I, too, am in agreement with pawsplay. If you've heard that Linda and Maggie have switched to Pathfinder, why not ask Linda and Maggie?
  13. Philosopher

    Pathfinder 1E Pathfinder + Psionics

    I would prefer that, actually. What makes it complex is not merely how it's worded, it's a matter of how much extra rules (beyond core) that are needed, and how they all interact. If psionic resistance is just the same as spell resistance (same goes for any other game concept), then you're...
  14. Philosopher

    Pathfinder 1E Pathfinder + Psionics

    If psionic resistance functions just like spell resistance, then there is no need to have psionic resistance. It's just needless complexity. Just as we don't need arcane resistance and divine resistance, we don't need psionic resistance. Psions just need to access the magic differently with...
  15. Philosopher

    An Older Experience System

    But how is this different from when you let them use gold to buy magic items?
Top