Effects of writers strike on Sci Fi & Fantasy genre

You mean because The Guardian of Forever appears in the Animated series' best episode? The Guardian also showed up in Discovery recently. I think, unless there was something weird about HE's initial contract, as work for hire, all rights indisputably belong to Paramount.

As for the actors, as far as I know, only three of them are still alive. Which is the case of most of the stuff from the 70s and earlier, anyone who might have an issue is busy being dead.
There have been more than a few lawsuits, in recent years, about "work for hire", most notably in the comic book world. Some of those came from the estates of creators, as the creators themselves had passed. Things can be rather murky and I mention Ellison, specifically because he doesn't shy away from lawsuits.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

There have been more than a few lawsuits, in recent years, about "work for hire", most notably in the comic book world. Some of those came from the estates of creators, as the creators themselves had passed. Things can be rather murky and I mention Ellison, specifically because he doesn't shy away from lawsuits.
Those have always been when shenanigans have been alleged over the original contracts. There is nothing to suggest HE's original contact was in any way shenanigistic, and HE has not challenged anything when the Guardian has appeared in live action, comics or novels. No matter how sympathetic he might feel towards the writers, he won't do anything when he hasn't got a leg to stand on.
 

Those have always been when shenanigans have been alleged over the original contracts. There is nothing to suggest HE's original contact was in any way shenanigistic, and HE has not challenged anything when the Guardian has appeared in live action, comics or novels. No matter how sympathetic he might feel towards the writers, he won't do anything when he hasn't got a leg to stand on.
Actually, Ellison did sue over the depiction of the Guardian in further material, back in 2009. Not sure hiw that worked out, but the Guardian has shown up in subsequent Star Trek stuff, and at any rate Ellison is currently unlikely to file any lawsuits from beyond the grave.
 


Actually, Ellison did sue over the depiction of the Guardian in further material, back in 2009. Not sure hiw that worked out, but the Guardian has shown up in subsequent Star Trek stuff, and at any rate Ellison is currently unlikely to file any lawsuits from beyond the grave.
As usual, a settlement. so no statement on value.

EDIT He passed away in 2018, so it would be his estate that would go after anything.

 



In case these weren’t shared already…

Neil Gaiman shared a list of the major sticking points between the different sides’ positions. It’s rather telling and kinda scary that there is seemingly no possible compromise on the AI points from the AMTPT.
 

Attachments

  • B538438C-D006-4BBD-B129-288433B26133.jpeg
    B538438C-D006-4BBD-B129-288433B26133.jpeg
    237.9 KB · Views: 81
  • 19890F46-901E-4D88-94F2-B07221667911.jpeg
    19890F46-901E-4D88-94F2-B07221667911.jpeg
    205.1 KB · Views: 78

As usual, a settlement. so no statement on value.

EDIT He passed away in 2018, so it would be his estate that would go after anything.

Fun fact, JMS (of Babylon 5 fame) is the executor of Harlan’s estate. Harlan’s long unpublished anthology The Last Dangerous Visions should be coming out soon and The Lost Aztec Temple of Mars (Harlan’s former home) will be turned into a museum.
 

Fun fact, JMS (of Babylon 5 fame) is the executor of Harlan’s estate. Harlan’s long unpublished anthology The Last Dangerous Visions should be coming out soon and The Lost Aztec Temple of Mars (Harlan’s former home) will be turned into a museum.
Ellison had a title something like "continuity consultant" for B5.
 

Remove ads

Top