Rystil Arden said:This is for the proposals' benefits as much as anything else. I know from Living ENWorld that judges are *much* more likely to vote on short proposals than ones with lots of stuff in them (and LEW has many more potential judges to vote on things than we do!). Proposal threads expect to have lively discussion in them as well (like the new spells thread). Besides, there's no need for hundreds of proposals unless there's someone who randomly proposes everything--we don't need to kitchen sink this: propose what is useful and we'll discuss it and add it on. That way, also, it is much much less likely that we will have to tell someone 'No' and take something away because we missed it.
I just don't see the problem with the classes being proposed in a single thread, as there aren't that many and a lot of discussion has already been had. For spells or feats, I guess individual threads might work, I just see it as easier as a player to get things voted in en masse if I wanted to use multiple things from a single book rather than making a single thread for each thing I was interested in potentially using.