Vemuz,
With a roar, you throw your impressive bulk at the man before you in a vicious lunge.
However, despite his fright, the man sees your intent, and swings the chair with all his might. This time, you feel the pain - a crushing impact on your elbow; your forearm goes numb for a few seconds. Feeling, and a stabbing pain with it, returns as you recover from your lunge, empty handed.
The man with the chair quickly retreats before you.
(OOC: Ooh, bad luck; not only did you fail the disarm check, but the AoO you provoked was a crit - 15 points of damage. I ruled that because you were reaching for the chair at the time, most of the damage was inflicted on your arm. Using the variant rules from the DMG for damage applied to specific limbs, your dominant arm is broken. -2 to attack rolls and STR checks.

Better luck next time...
Damage tally: 20 points subdual so far...)
Malthas,
The bottle wielder, seeing Nicodemus's reeling strike, easily knocks it away. However, in doing so, he opens himself up to a sneak attack by you. This time, your sap meets the back of skull in exactly the right place. Staggered, the Standishtowner stumbles out of your reach to collect his wits.
And the same time, you hear a whistling noise close by your ear; the wounded Standishtowner has recovered his courage and darted back into the fray. The whistling noise was his fist, passing close enough by your ear to ruffle your hair.
(OOC: You inflicted 11 points of subdual damage on the Standishtowner.)
Nicodemus,
The Standishtowner had been vacillating as to who to hit, but upon hearing you cast doubt upon his heritage, he turns to you in time to avoid your spirited, but drunken, blow.
"Fancy words from a hairy tarbucket who drinks with Half-Porc - Urk!" His insult is cut short as Malthas's sap meets the base of his skull, enough to send him reeling like a landsman in a gale. Clutching the back of his head, he steps back out of range to gather his wits.
At the same time, you see the wounded Standishtowner re-enter the fray, his fist just missing Malthas.
Malachi,
Grabbing your assailant by the hair, you swing him in an impressive arc, which is cut short by the bar. You keep a firm grip on your assailant's hair, but his fellows are all over you.
A pair of blows to heavy open up your lip and send a stream of blood down your chin, but you doggedly retain your grip on the third Standishtowner.
(OOC: You inflicted 6 points subdual on the Standishtowner. You know have him in a grapple; you can either pin him, holding him immobile for one round, or you can throttle him, inflicting 1d3+STR every round you keep a hold on him.
The other Standishtowners inflicted 9 points total of subdual damage on you.)