Lanefan
Victoria Rules
I would, in that it would render lighter-weight characters near useless in combat. Picture your archetypal swashbuckler, with a rapier in one hand and a dagger in the other; all dex, little or no strength; kills by a thousand cuts rather than by one big blow; and then ask if that character concept would even be viable if going against armoured foes.Not sure I have a problem with that, actually.
If the answer is "no it wouldn't", there's a system problem. And adding a version of 'weapon finesse' isn't the answer, as dexterity is too important as a stat already.