While Penkus' unblemished appearance is rather hard to fathom due to his fetid, bloated condition, it does seem that Kalen's disguise should be a passable resemblance to the dead thief. Of course, the only way to find out for sure would be to put it to the test against his former allies.
Col relents from his insistence on bringing the dead Penkus back into Sasserine, as he finds little support for the idea amongst his companions. However, everyone agrees that the treasure found below must be taken along tonight. To that end, the six adventurers work together, using rope and muscle to haul out the coins, gems, and magic items. It takes some time, and when the rowboat is finally loaded, the sun has nearly set, and the group is so exhausted that everyone feels as though they could drop at any second. Still, they know they can't stay the night on the island. Clambering into the (very crowded) boat, Chongo and Keoni take the oars, and the party shoves off, heading for the lights of Shadowshore.
The trip takes a bit longer than it might normally, due to the fatigue of the rowers, but the boat lands at a small, unobserved dock without incident. The party sets foot on the welcome wood of the dock, more than 36 hours since departing with Shefton for Parrot Island. The companions know that they need to rendezvous with Lavinia and inform her on what they've learned...but what to do with the treasure chests?
[OOC: You guys want to lug the treasure through the streets, or try to stash it somewhere? Note, I'm really talking about the bulky coins, not so much the easily portable gems, potions, etc.]