Star Wars Mando season 3

Whizbang Dustyboots

Gnometown Hero
I also don't think the whole "everyone wears helmets all the time" deal is really the smart move that I suspect Favreau thinks it is, either - especially when they're wearing armour, and he's not writing/shooting the shows in such a way as to show off their body language particularly well (i.e. not any better than you would in a show when you could see their face). All it does is rob the show of humanity and energy, and the sooner it's over, the better. If we have to deal with all the characters having their helmets on AND they're the focus of the entire season, that's really going to be a massive drag on already-weak writing and plotting.
It's notable to me that only Katee Sackhoff still manages to carry herself in a distinct way in the armor. She's got a lot of experience of doing genre work and already carries herself like an athlete in real life. But almost everyone else is an anonymous schlub in the armor, which isn't great.
 

log in or register to remove this ad


Reef

Hero
It's notable to me that only Katee Sackhoff still manages to carry herself in a distinct way in the armor. She's got a lot of experience of doing genre work and already carries herself like an athlete in real life. But almost everyone else is an anonymous schlub in the armor, which isn't great.
True, and this is probably why it's more noticeable this season. In previous ones, Din was the only one in a helmet, and he could still manage while interacting with Greef, Cara, the widow in the village, etc. With this episode, everyone is wearing a helmet. Katee Sackhoff manages to project a character when in armour, to her great credit, but it was still better when she could use her face.
 


Maxperson

Morkus from Orkus
The whole "eating apart" thing flies in the face of basic humanity, camaraderie and like every military organisation in human history, and is profoundly demented (Bo Katan did seem to be displeased with it at least, rather than being all "This Is The Way").
LOL Yeah. I thought to myself, "If you want to defeat the Mandalorians, just wait until lunch time and then attack."
The most disorganised and needlessly dangerous climb in history - like, you pick a route, and you all follow it, learning from your fellow climbers - you don't all separately climb the mountain together. So needlessly weird. With a better writer I'd say it was intentionally emblematic of how disorganised and individualist the cult-Mandalorians seem to be. Here I think Favreau just has never climbed anything in his damn life (amazing, given even I have), and never bothered to think about how it work work. So the kid is fine after god-knows-how-long in some internal pouch (we have to assume not a stomach) of this pterosaur? Weird. And now Bo Katan wants to join the cult? At least she got dumb-as-a-box-rocks mystical bollocks answers out of Hammer Lady. Again, with a better writer, I'd assume that left her disappointed, but we can't assume that with Favreau.
I got the impression that since they can fly, climbing isn't their thing. They seemed to struggle, which makes sense with their armor. My big issue with that scene was that a day later, after losing the big dragon thing in the air, it shows up to spit out the kid in order to feed its young just as they show up.
 


Whizbang Dustyboots

Gnometown Hero
I got the impression that since they can fly, climbing isn't their thing. They seemed to struggle, which makes sense with their armor. My big issue with that scene was that a day later, after losing the big dragon thing in the air, it shows up to spit out the kid in order to feed its young just as they show up.
Wrist-mounted steel cables are also terrible ways to climb.
 





BASHMAN

Basic Action Games
I loved the episode, but could not wrap my head around why the mother took so long to feed the babies? Bo tracked it back to its nest, flew back to the covert, told them all about it, they made a battle plan, flew back out, camped for the night, climbed the big rock pillar for many more hours... and the creature only then showed up to regurgitate the young mando (who somehow didn't suffocate). He'd been in her mouth for a day and a half at this point.
But again, I did like the show; just wish they had some sort of explanation for this (like the eggs hadn't hatched yet and mama was waiting for them).
 

Rabulias

the Incomparably Shrewd and Clever
I think I get why they had the helmet thing for the first part of the show. It provided some tension when Din infiltrated the Imperial base, and (more importantly, IMO), it made for the very dramatic moment at the end of season 2. When Din removes his helmet to say goodbye to Grogu, it is very moving scene, and shows how much Grogu has come to mean to Din. It reminds me of Vader's death in Return of the Jedi ("Let me look upon you with my own eyes."). Finally it gave Din a motive to go to Mandalore, leading into the current season.

Now I think they have tapped the well dry, and the helmet taboo is hindering the show more than it helps it, which is why I hope Bo-Katan leads them away from it.
 

Whizbang Dustyboots

Gnometown Hero
I think I get why they had the helmet thing for the first part of the show. It provided some tension when Din infiltrated the Imperial base, and (more importantly, IMO), it made for the very dramatic moment at the end of season 2. When Din removes his helmet to say goodbye to Grogu, it is very moving scene, and shows how much Grogu has come to mean to Din. It reminds me of Vader's death in Return of the Jedi ("Let me look upon you with my own eyes."). Finally it gave Din a motive to go to Mandalore, leading into the current season.
As with so many things in Star Wars, though, they could have accomplished all that, and avoided the problems, just by sitting down and plotting it out a bit further into the future.

"So, we're going to have him meet other Mandalorians at some point. Does he wear his helmet with them? Why not? How do they eat? How do they make baby Mandalorians? Are they all covered with zits under their helmets? Don't we want to see the various actors' faces sometimes? We can just have the Armorer and some of the more hardcore folks keep their helmets on by choice, right?"

Since this all came after everyone saw how not planning the sequel trilogy worked out, step one of doing anything Star Wars should be plotting things out further than the end of the first movie or season, ideally to encompass the whole arc of a series or new trilogy.
 

Zaukrie

New Publisher
As with so many things in Star Wars, though, they could have accomplished all that, and avoided the problems, just by sitting down and plotting it out a bit further into the future.

"So, we're going to have him meet other Mandalorians at some point. Does he wear his helmet with them? Why not? How do they eat? How do they make baby Mandalorians? Are they all covered with zits under their helmets? Don't we want to see the various actors' faces sometimes? We can just have the Armorer and some of the more hardcore folks keep their helmets on by choice, right?"

Since this all came after everyone saw how not planning the sequel trilogy worked out, step one of doing anything Star Wars should be plotting things out further than the end of the first movie or season, ideally to encompass the whole arc of a series or new trilogy.
I don't think SW has a long term plan....unless it is recycle the past and only tell Skywalker adjacent stories. that's, like, the extent of the plan (in fairness, neither Andor nor the Mandalorian are stuck on Skywalkers, which is nice).
 


MarkB

Legend
As with so many things in Star Wars, though, they could have accomplished all that, and avoided the problems, just by sitting down and plotting it out a bit further into the future.

"So, we're going to have him meet other Mandalorians at some point. Does he wear his helmet with them? Why not? How do they eat? How do they make baby Mandalorians? Are they all covered with zits under their helmets? Don't we want to see the various actors' faces sometimes? We can just have the Armorer and some of the more hardcore folks keep their helmets on by choice, right?"
To be fair, they pretty much did that in the first two seasons, showing that other Mandalorians don't adhere to this custom and having Din compromise it for the sake of his ward, while also having his faction be decimated down to a handful of members. And now they're doing a Rise of Skywalker, getting intimidated by the daring of their own character development, trying to walk it back and overcompensating.
Since this all came after everyone saw how not planning the sequel trilogy worked out, step one of doing anything Star Wars should be plotting things out further than the end of the first movie or season, ideally to encompass the whole arc of a series or new trilogy.
Plans change. The success of The Mandalorian has done much to propel the greenlighting of other Star Wars series projects, and those in turn will have influenced the course of this show.
 

Ryujin

Legend
I don't think SW has a long term plan....unless it is recycle the past and only tell Skywalker adjacent stories. that's, like, the extent of the plan (in fairness, neither Andor nor the Mandalorian are stuck on Skywalkers, which is nice).
I would say that you're right. I doubt that anyone, even Lucas, has ever sat down and seriously written a "world bible" that outlines how things work and are connected. No plotted history. There are too many things that just jump out of the woodwork.
 

Zaukrie

New Publisher
I would say that you're right. I doubt that anyone, even Lucas, has ever sat down and seriously written a "world bible" that outlines how things work and are connected. No plotted history. There are too many things that just jump out of the woodwork.
It's too bad, because there is one on line somewhere (of the past and future works), but I don't feel Disney has a real plan (that's clear from the last three movies).
 


Epic Threats

An Advertisement

Advertisement4

Top