I listen when I can, and also participate on the IRC channel.
However, it is usually quite difficult for me to do so (listen, that is) and I rarely get to hear the whole show live.
Why? Time of the show.
I am on the west coast and the show starts at 5:00 pm here. That means I'm not yet home from work (heck, 99% of the time I haven't even left work by 5:00) and by the time I get home, the show is usually at least half over (I'm not going to stay at work to listen to the show until 7:00 or 7:30 when it ends).
If the show was bumped back one more hour - to 9:00 local time, 6:00 out here - I could probably listen more. As it is, I just can't.
=============================
Reactions to the show (likes/dislikes):
I enjoy the reviews - I like the casual style.
I enjoy getting to hear scoops and trends within the industry - and to "meet" some of the industry's movers and shakers.
I'm not particularly fond of the "technology" on interviews (microphone pushed up to a speakerphone) - it's usually very hard to hear the guest intelligibly. While I love the interviews when I can hear them clearly, all too often I can't hear them clearly. That's a problem
Also, the show seems a little - well - disorganized. There is a LOT of dead air time and "stalling." There is a saying in radio to the effect of "dead air is the worst offense you can have." That includes two to three minutes of "umm... uh... let me see here..." while things get ready. I think a half-hour spent organizing a "timetable" for the show just before the show start can't hurt.
Finally, I would like to see "themed shows" - by which I mean, give the callers a bit of advance notice on the website (a day or two) about the show's main topic - be it "Neverwinter Nights" or "reactions to GenCon" or "Elves vs. Dwarves". This lets people ask intelligent questions instead of rambling. While there's nothing wrong with "open forum" occasionally, all too often it makes for no meaningful discussion.
I guess you might take as a model a sports talk show - this time of year there are lots of topics - football season and whose moves look good and whose don't; baseball pennant races; the U.S. Open (Tennis); the Basketball World Championships and so on... most hosts put several topics out there and ask for a response to any of them, but at least there's some direction there. Similarly, Mortality might do something along the lines of "comparing Heroes of High Favor: Dwarves, Quint. Dwarf, and Hammer & Helm" - which do you find most useful? Why? Are you looking forward to the MMII's release? What 4th quarter release are you looking forward to? How do you handle high-level gaming?
I guess just pick a half-dozen topics related to gaming and the gaming industry and go from there. The show as is seems to completely lack focus. In radio - internet radio included, that's the one biggest no-no, as it contributes greatly to dead air.
--The Sigil