Just to carry on the discussion about misqueues a little more: it reminds me of something that happened to me years ago. One morning I was walking across a parking lot on my way into work and I noticed a .223 caliber rifle round lying on the ground. I picked it up, put it in my pocket and continued on as if nothing were out of the ordinary.
Out of context that probably seems to be a very odd (perhaps even insane or at least very negligent) reaction. But...in context....I was at the time deployed to Iraq and the parking lot was used as a staging area by my unit for loading vehicles prior to going out on combat missions. Soldiers often loaded ammo there. So it wasn't at all strange to find a bit of stray ammo lying about and since later that day I would be going outside the base I just put the round in one of my magazines that was short a couple rounds.
Your lack of reaction to the information I presented strikes me as being like that. So I figured I was miscommunicating something. Now I think I understand where i went wrong.
From now on, at least when you succeed at a check I will try to be more precise at what you succeeded in doing.