The FAQ is not errata... it merely clarifies the current rules (which are pretty obvious in this matter). The FAQ answer is mentioning ranged touch attacks because that was the question it was answering. I did not include the full question earlier for brevity, but here it is:Darklone said:So why should I assume that errate explicitely referring to ranged touch attacks can be applied to melee touch attacks?
Dragon Mage said:Where does it state in the rules the "the touch attack itself is part of the casting"?
FAQ said:The caster uses
the cast a spell action (a standard action), and makes all the
ranged touch attacks the spell allows as part of that standard
action (not as part of the attack or full attack action)
I agree with that, but you say it's obvious and yet it's the point of confusion. I don't think Darklone was agreeing with that.Philodendron said:[states the obvious] If you cast a melee touch attack spell normally, the touch attack itself is part of the casting action [/states the obvious]
Darklone specifically questioned the validity of this statement by mvincent: "Touching a target is part of casting the spell, and so can be quickened." I don't understand his point because I don't understand which part of this sentence he doesn't agree with and why. If, as you said, the first part is merely stating the obvious, then it begs the question as to why he doesn't agree with the second part. Quicken Spell speeds up casting the spell, so QED if the first part of this sentence is a given. There's really nothing more to it after that.Philodendron said:Darkalone was (I think) wondering whether quickening the spell casting also quickens the melee touch attack, or if it only quickens the touching part if you are touching willing subjects.
It seems to me that the melee touch attack must also be quickened.
Agreed that there are differences, but the first question is whether or not you agree with the statement that touching someone is part of casting the spell (same e.g. contagion). If yes, then any other points about holding the charge or whatnot become irrelevant to the point at hand. If no, then there are much bigger issues to handle.Darklone said:What I meant: Ranged touch spells and melee touch spells have some huge differences, the biggest is about holding the charge.