D&D 5E Survey: What should the next Magic the Gathering Campaign Setting be?

[Urriak Uruk]

The title speaks for itself, but of the last three settings released, two have been more Magic the Gathering. Two does not a pattern make, but it's fairly likely we'll see another book release for a Magic setting if we've gotten two in the past few years.

My question is, now that Ravnica and Theros are off the table, what do you think should be given priority? Personally, I love the ideas between the new ones like Eldraine or Ikoria, but I also really like the more developed one's, especially a world like Tarkir.

I've also included the "None" option, because I know some people loathe this who concept.

If you don't know anything about these planes, here are some sources;
MAGIC STORY (scroll to the bottom and select "settings" for each one I've listed)

The Rabiah Scale, Wizard's internal scoring system for revisiting planes. Is out-of-date so does not truly reflect their current POV, but a useful tool nonetheless.

The Rabiah Scale, Part 1 | MAGIC: THE GATHERING

Mark uses the Rabiah Scale to examine how likely he believes we are to return to a particular plane in a Standard-legal set.

magic.wizards.com

The Rabiah Scale, Part 2 | MAGIC: THE GATHERING

Mark wraps up his look at how likely he thinks we are to return to each plane Magic has already visited.

magic.wizards.com

 

[Weiley31]

I just want Eldaraine so I can make that Gingerbread Planeswalker!

 

[DND_Reborn]

Thanks for including a "None" option. Many times I have to ask for one to be added.

 

[Charlaquin]

I would prefer they not do any more magic settings (as hardcover published books - I thought the planeshift series was pretty dope) but since that’s definitely not going to happen, I voted for the plane I would least dislike for them to do next, which is Dominaria.

 

[LuisCarlos17f]

Kamigawa is too "one-shot" for a setting. I guess something linked with a future Oriental Adventures, and this with the remake of the martial adept classes (crusader, swordsage and warblade).

Eldraine is enough open for new stories. It has got more points to be adapted.

 

[Bitbrain]

If we consider the Planeshift PDFs as campaign guides, then I’d like to see a Tarkir hardcover. The artwork for that setting is EPIC.

If we do not consider the Planeshift PDFs as campaign guides, then I’d like to see Ixalan get a hardcover before anything else. Amonkhet after that.

More than anything else though (and I know I sound like a broken record here), I wants an official 5e Dark Sun campaign Guide!

 

[PsyzhranV2]

Speaking as an outsider to MtG, and after consulting the links in the OP, reviewing a previous post of OP's that went over the planes in more detail, and doing my own research, the plane that resonated with me the most was New Phyrexia. From a first impression, it has a distinct enough identity that it could justify itself and not overlap with existing properties, both MtG and D&D.

Lorwyn-Shadowmoor also interests me, but apparently that plane is in limbo meta-wise? A lot of plot threads were left unfinished, and I am skeptical of a 5e sourcebook being the best way to resolve them and/or reimagine the setting.

 

[Lanefan]

I'd really like them to do Kamigawa as a full-on setting. Of that list it's probably the only one I'd be almost sure to buy.

 

[Tonguez]

How much is Innistrad like Ravenloft? Is it good Gothic?

 

[Li Shenron]

Some of these were released as small free pdfs, I think they were maybe Zendikar, Kaladesh and either Innistrad or Shandalar. I wonder if this makes it more or less probable they will ever get a hardback supplement.