Survivor D&D Computer Games- Baldur's Gate WINS!

[McTreble]

AD&D: Cloudy Mountain 15
Baldur's Gate 24
Baldur's Gate II 25
Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance Series 14
Chronicles of Mystara 20
Dungeons & Dragons Online 7
Eye of the Beholder Series 21
Gold Box: Pool of Radiance Series 18
Gold Box: Dragonlance Series 20
Gold Box: Savage Frontier Series 20
Gold Box: Spelljammer 18
Icewind Dale 18
Icewind Dale II 20
Neverwinter Nights 25 +1=26
Neverwinter Nights II 22
Planescape: Torment 19
SSI Dark Sun Series 18
Temple of Elemental Evil 19
Warriors of the Eternal Sun 21 -2 = 19

 

[Gladius Legis]

AD&D: Cloudy Mountain 15
Baldur's Gate 24
Baldur's Gate II 25
Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance Series 14
Chronicles of Mystara 20
Dungeons & Dragons Online 5 - Why is this piece of garbage still alive?
Eye of the Beholder Series 21
Gold Box: Pool of Radiance Series 18
Gold Box: Dragonlance Series 20
Gold Box: Savage Frontier Series 20
Gold Box: Spelljammer 18
Icewind Dale 18
Icewind Dale II 20
Neverwinter Nights 26
Neverwinter Nights II 22
Planescape: Torment 20 - Protect this masterpiece from edgelord invaders.
SSI Dark Sun Series 18
Temple of Elemental Evil 19
Warriors of the Eternal Sun 19

 

[Paul Farquhar]

AD&D: Cloudy Mountain 15
Baldur's Gate 24
Baldur's Gate II 25
Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance Series 14
Chronicles of Mystara 20
Dungeons & Dragons Online 3 - Why is this piece of garbage still alive?
Eye of the Beholder Series 21
Gold Box: Pool of Radiance Series 18
Gold Box: Dragonlance Series 20
Gold Box: Savage Frontier Series 20
Gold Box: Spelljammer 18
Icewind Dale 18
Icewind Dale II 20
Neverwinter Nights 26
Neverwinter Nights II 22
Planescape: Torment 21 - Protect this masterpiece from edgelord invaders.
SSI Dark Sun Series 18
Temple of Elemental Evil 19
Warriors of the Eternal Sun 19



I agree 100% with these comments.

 

[Imaculata]

AD&D: Cloudy Mountain 15
Baldur's Gate 24
Baldur's Gate II 25
Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance Series 14
Chronicles of Mystara 20
Dungeons & Dragons Online 4 - Have you actually played it?
Eye of the Beholder Series 21
Gold Box: Pool of Radiance Series 18
Gold Box: Dragonlance Series 20
Gold Box: Savage Frontier Series 20
Gold Box: Spelljammer 18
Icewind Dale 18
Icewind Dale II 20
Neverwinter Nights 26
Neverwinter Nights II 22
Planescape: Torment 21
SSI Dark Sun Series 18
Temple of Elemental Evil 17
Warriors of the Eternal Sun 19

 

[Maxperson]

AD&D: Cloudy Mountain 15
Baldur's Gate 24
Baldur's Gate II 25
Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance Series 14
Chronicles of Mystara 20
Dungeons & Dragons Online 4
Eye of the Beholder Series 21
Gold Box: Pool of Radiance Series 16
Gold Box: Dragonlance Series 20
Gold Box: Savage Frontier Series 20
Gold Box: Spelljammer 18
Icewind Dale 18
Icewind Dale II 20
Neverwinter Nights 26
Neverwinter Nights II 22
Planescape: Torment 21
SSI Dark Sun Series 18
Temple of Elemental Evil 18
Warriors of the Eternal Sun 19

 

[Maxperson]

Have you actually played it?

I know that you weren't directing that at me, but I have not. The only reason I didn't was that several of my friends did play it and none of them liked it.

 

[Paul Farquhar]

I know that you weren't directing that at me, but I have not. The only reason I didn't was that several of my friends did play it and none of them liked it.

I've played it. It sucked. Visually uninspired, tagged on twitch gameplay, and a clumsy attempt at a rest system that didn't really work in in a MMO context.

 

[OB1]

AD&D: Cloudy Mountain 15
Baldur's Gate 24
Baldur's Gate II 25
Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance Series 14
Chronicles of Mystara 20
Dungeons & Dragons Online 4
Eye of the Beholder Series 21
Gold Box: Pool of Radiance Series 16+1=17
Gold Box: Dragonlance Series 20
Gold Box: Savage Frontier Series 20
Gold Box: Spelljammer 18
Icewind Dale 18
Icewind Dale II 20
Neverwinter Nights 26
Neverwinter Nights II 22
Planescape: Torment 21
SSI Dark Sun Series 18
Temple of Elemental Evil 18-2=16
Warriors of the Eternal Sun 19

 

[Sacrosanct]

AD&D: Cloudy Mountain 16
Baldur's Gate 24
Baldur's Gate II 25
Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance Series 14
Chronicles of Mystara 20
Dungeons & Dragons Online 4
Eye of the Beholder Series 21
Gold Box: Pool of Radiance Series 17
Gold Box: Dragonlance Series 20
Gold Box: Savage Frontier Series 20
Gold Box: Spelljammer 18
Icewind Dale 18
Icewind Dale II 20
Neverwinter Nights 26
Neverwinter Nights II 22
Planescape: Torment 19
SSI Dark Sun Series 18
Temple of Elemental Evil 16
Warriors of the Eternal Sun 19

 

[Tyler Do'Urden]

AD&D: Cloudy Mountain 15
Baldur's Gate 24
Baldur's Gate II 26
Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance Series 14
Chronicles of Mystara 20
Dungeons & Dragons Online 4
Eye of the Beholder Series 21
Gold Box: Pool of Radiance Series 17
Gold Box: Dragonlance Series 20
Gold Box: Savage Frontier Series 20
Gold Box: Spelljammer 18
Icewind Dale 18
Icewind Dale II 20
Neverwinter Nights 24 Couldn't get into it. Found it a disappointment after BG/IWD/Torment. Mainly because there were no parties or NPCs.
Neverwinter Nights II 22
Planescape: Torment 21
SSI Dark Sun Series 18
Temple of Elemental Evil 16
Warriors of the Eternal Sun 19

 

[Sacrosanct]

AD&D: Cloudy Mountain 15
Baldur's Gate 24
Baldur's Gate II 26
Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance Series 14
Chronicles of Mystara 20
Dungeons & Dragons Online 4
Eye of the Beholder Series 21
Gold Box: Pool of Radiance Series 17
Gold Box: Dragonlance Series 20
Gold Box: Savage Frontier Series 20
Gold Box: Spelljammer 18
Icewind Dale 18
Icewind Dale II 20
Neverwinter Nights 24 Couldn't get into it. Found it a disappointment after BG/IWD/Torment. Mainly because there were no parties or NPCs.
Neverwinter Nights II 22
Planescape: Torment 21
SSI Dark Sun Series 18
Temple of Elemental Evil 16
Warriors of the Eternal Sun 19

We posted at almost the same time, so you'll need to update your results with my votes. Also, I'm a bit confused. Neverwinter nights was party based and had NPCS. Are you thinking of a different game perhaps?

 

[Ristamar]

I accounted for the previous tally error.


AD&D: Cloudy Mountain 14
Baldur's Gate 24
Baldur's Gate II 27
Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance Series 14
Chronicles of Mystara 20
Dungeons & Dragons Online 4
Eye of the Beholder Series 21
Gold Box: Pool of Radiance Series 17
Gold Box: Dragonlance Series 20
Gold Box: Savage Frontier Series 20
Gold Box: Spelljammer 18
Icewind Dale 18
Icewind Dale II 20
Neverwinter Nights 24
Neverwinter Nights II 22
Planescape: Torment 19
SSI Dark Sun Series 18
Temple of Elemental Evil 16
Warriors of the Eternal Sun 19

 

[Tyler Do'Urden]

We posted at almost the same time, so you'll need to update your results with my votes. Also, I'm a bit confused. Neverwinter nights was party based and had NPCS. Are you thinking of a different game perhaps?

I remember when it first came out and I could only control one character plus a sidekick. We could play multiplayer with parties... but it wasn't like the Infinity Engine games.

 

[BookBarbarian]

I remember when it first came out and I could only control one character plus a sidekick. We could play multiplayer with parties... but it wasn't like the Infinity Engine games.

The main campaign of NWN 1 single player had only on follower. the Hordes of the Underdark expansion increase that to 2. It was NWN 2 where you controlled a party of 4.

 

[akr71]

AD&D: Cloudy Mountain 14
Baldur's Gate 24
Baldur's Gate II 27
Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance Series 14
Chronicles of Mystara 20
Dungeons & Dragons Online 4
Eye of the Beholder Series 21
Gold Box: Pool of Radiance Series 17
Gold Box: Dragonlance Series 20
Gold Box: Savage Frontier Series 20
Gold Box: Spelljammer 18
Icewind Dale 18
Icewind Dale II 20
Neverwinter Nights 24
Neverwinter Nights II 22
Planescape: Torment 19
SSI Dark Sun Series 18
Temple of Elemental Evil 14
Warriors of the Eternal Sun 19

 

[Prakriti]

AD&D: Cloudy Mountain 14
Baldur's Gate 24
Baldur's Gate II 27
Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance Series 14
Chronicles of Mystara 20
Dungeons & Dragons Online 5
Eye of the Beholder Series 21
Gold Box: Pool of Radiance Series 17
Gold Box: Dragonlance Series 20
Gold Box: Savage Frontier Series 20
Gold Box: Spelljammer 18
Icewind Dale 18
Icewind Dale II 20
Neverwinter Nights 24
Neverwinter Nights II 22
Planescape: Torment 19
SSI Dark Sun Series 18
Temple of Elemental Evil 12
Warriors of the Eternal Sun 19

 

[Gradine]

AD&D: Cloudy Mountain 14-2=12
Baldur's Gate 24
Baldur's Gate II 27
Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance Series 14
Chronicles of Mystara 20
Dungeons & Dragons Online 5
Eye of the Beholder Series 21
Gold Box: Pool of Radiance Series 17
Gold Box: Dragonlance Series 20
Gold Box: Savage Frontier Series 20
Gold Box: Spelljammer 18
Icewind Dale 18
Icewind Dale II 20
Neverwinter Nights 24
Neverwinter Nights II 22
Planescape: Torment 19+1=20
SSI Dark Sun Series 18
Temple of Elemental Evil 12
Warriors of the Eternal Sun 19

 

[Ristamar]

Neverwinter Nights should be at 25 (assuming the green upvote from [MENTION=6801213]akr71[/MENTION] is the correct intent).

 

[Sacrosanct]

Honestly, the best D&D game I've played isn't a real D&D game: Borderland 2, Tiny Tina's DLC. Felt more like D&D than half of the games on this list, and more fun than almost any of them.

 

[CleverNickName]

AD&D: Cloudy Mountain 12
Baldur's Gate 24
Baldur's Gate II 27
Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance Series 14
Chronicles of Mystara 20
Dungeons & Dragons Online 5
Eye of the Beholder Series 21
Gold Box: Pool of Radiance Series 17
Gold Box: Dragonlance Series 20
Gold Box: Savage Frontier Series 20
Gold Box: Spelljammer 18
Icewind Dale 18
Icewind Dale II 20
Neverwinter Nights 24
Neverwinter Nights II 22
Planescape: Torment 20-2=18
SSI Dark Sun Series 18
Temple of Elemental Evil 12+1=13
Warriors of the Eternal Sun 19

I've only ever played a handful of these. Ah, the memories...