D&D 5E Survivor: The Other CLasses Vote Em off the Island

[Sacrosanct]

I'm just sad this poll didn't include the following classes:

Ninja
Duelist (1e)
Neanderthal (1e)

 

[ChrisCarlson]

Alchemist (various) 17
Artificer (2E Spells and Magic)/Eberron 21
Curry Lord (makes lemon curry) 20
Gunslinger (Pathfinder) 21
Healer (3E) 11
Jedi (SWSE) 20
Jester (1E) 15
Mystic (2E) 20
Psion(2E-4E) 18
Thief-Acrobat (1E) 23
Warden (4E) 20
Warlord (4E) 10


(Oh, and I just want it out there that the capital L is annoying. Sorry, couldn't resist... )

 

[Rhogar_Rarr]

Alchemist (various) 17
Artificer (2E Spells and Magic)/Eberron 21
Curry Lord (makes lemon curry) 20
Gunslinger (Pathfinder) 21
Healer (3E) 8 (Just sounds boring)
Jedi (SWSE) 20
Jester (1E) 15
Mystic (2E) 20
Psion(2E-4E) 18
Thief-Acrobat (1E) 23
Warden (4E) 20
Warlord (4E) 11 (I did really enjoy this in 4E)

My second pick would probably be gunslinger. It's one that I've always wanted to try out, but haven't gotten around to yet.

 

[EdL]

Alchemist (various) 18
Artificer (2E Spells and Magic)/Eberron 21
Curry Lord (makes lemon curry) 20
Gunslinger (Pathfinder) 21
Healer (3E) 8 (Just sounds boring)
Jedi (SWSE) 20
Jester (1E) 12
Mystic (2E) 20
Psion(2E-4E) 18
Thief-Acrobat (1E) 23
Warden (4E) 20
Warlord (4E) 11 (I did really enjoy this in 4E)

Alchemist +1
Jester -3

 

[mcmillan]

Alchemist (various) 18
Artificer (2E Spells and Magic)/Eberron 21
Curry Lord (makes lemon curry) 20
Gunslinger (Pathfinder) 21
Healer (3E) 8
Jedi (SWSE) 20
Jester (1E) 12
Mystic (2E) 20
Psion(2E-4E) 18
Thief-Acrobat (1E) 20
Warden (4E) 20
Warlord (4E) 12

Warlord +1
Thief-Acrobat -3

 

[ZzarkLinux]

Alchemist (various) 18
Artificer (2E Spells and Magic)/Eberron 21
Curry Lord (makes lemon curry) 20
Gunslinger (Pathfinder) 21
Healer (3E) 8
Jedi (SWSE) 20
Jester (1E) 12
Mystic (2E) 20
Psion(2E-4E) 18
Thief-Acrobat (1E) 20
Warden (4E) 17
Warlord (4E) 13

I played 4th. Despite it's many flaws, I liked the warlord at my table.
Rebuking the warden to remind everyone that even 4e fans hate the many flaws it had.

Is the warlord allowed to shout back his lost points in this edition of survivor?

 

[steeldragons]

Alright...day...three? Yes, three.

*sigh* I suppose we ought to start ripping into these other ones that I'd like to see gone. Yes. There are [several] others I would like removed...but this thread, in comparison to the other Survivor threads seems particularly slow moving. Other's can continue whittling away at the war-lush.

So...

Alchemist (various) 19
Artificer (2E Spells and Magic)/Eberron 21
Curry Lord (makes lemon curry) 20
Gunslinger (Pathfinder) 21
Healer (3E) 8
Jedi (SWSE) 17
Jester (1E) 12
Mystic (2E) 20
Psion(2E-4E) 18
Thief-Acrobat (1E) 20
Warden (4E) 17
Warlord (4E) 13

"-" to Jedi cuz...well, this is a supposed to be a D&D poll/classes for a D&D [hypothetical] game, is it not? Let's keep it within genre/franchise, shall we.

"+" to Alchemist 1) cuz Acrobat seems to be doing fine for now and 2) I think the PF alchemist was a cool concept (though I wouldn't of course, have implemented it the same way) and can definitely see an Alchemist as a character in D&D and, specific to 5e, would be super simple to just make them a subclass of Bard...and 3) cuz, why not?

I'll be back to peck at things tomorrow.

 

[lowkey13]

*Deleted by user*

 

[Rhogar_Rarr]

Alchemist (various) 19
Artificer (2E Spells and Magic)/Eberron 21
Curry Lord (makes lemon curry) 17
Gunslinger (Pathfinder) 21
Healer (3E) 8
Jedi (SWSE) 17
Jester (1E) 9
Mystic (2E) 20
Psion(2E-4E) 18
Thief-Acrobat (1E) 21
Warden (4E) 17
Warlord (4E) 14

Still got some love for the tactical class. Gotta make some red curry, not lemon curry.

 

[GMforPowergamers]

Alchemist (various) 19
Artificer (2E Spells and Magic)/Eberron 21
Curry Lord (makes lemon curry) 17
Gunslinger (Pathfinder) 21
Healer (3E) 8
Jedi (SWSE) 17
Jester (1E) 6
Mystic (2E) 20
Psion(2E-4E) 18
Thief-Acrobat (1E) 21
Warden (4E) 17
Warlord (4E) 15


Jester and healer are both on the ropes, and I can't belive it but gunslinger and theif-acrobat are ties with the artificer for the lead