Which +1 Weapon Magical Ability is best ?

[Shard O'Glase]

Keen sucks I think for a crit range 20 weapon. It rocks for a rapier or scimitar though. I like frost more than fire and consistent d6 damage gets brutal.(I dig the idea of freezing things like water with the frost effect, even if it is small amounts I think it is a cool special effect)

Spell storing I think has a creator level of 12, so I think it is beyond this 7th level mage.

And as I understood the magic weapon creation rules you can give a bonus of your level/3 enhancement bonuses stop at 5. So a +2/+2(special abilities would be possible). Am I wrong is it only level/3 for enhancement bonuses and you can throw on as many other bonuses as you want as long as the total is +10 or less and you have the exp and money to blow?

 

[Skullfyre]

Keen is always a nice choice.

Especially if you have Improved Crit for that Great Axe

this is only if the person has a +8BAB so he would need to be at least 9th to get the feat

 

[Rashak Mani]

Take a peek at the future owner of that Great Axe:

http://www.enworld.org/messageboards/showthread.php?s=&threadid=3961

Link to Rogues Gallery of the Character I am planning to make a weapon for ... as soon as we get to the City of Greyhawk.

 

[Little_Buddha]

this is only if the person has a +8BAB so he would need to be at least 9th to get the feat

No, he'd have to be at least eighth level. The only requirement is a BAB of +8. A Human Barbarian7 could take a level of Fighter, for example, and thereby get Improved Critical at character level eight.