D&D General Pellet bow?

Cleon · Nov 13, 2018

Greenfield said:
The other invention they explored was a giant crossbow designed to hurl stones. They built and rebuilt this one, and near the end of the show they fired it.

The machine was huge, by the way, and the stone they threw was about the size of a grapefruit. Maybe a small melon. It went about 60 feet total, and while they called it a success, I saw it as a dismal failure.

I remember that show or one much like it.

The design was so obviously doomed that one wonders whether Leonardo did it deliberately - I do recall reading stories that he didn't like to invent weapons and sabotaged some of his designs.

It's pretty much impossible to build a large tension-powered missile thrower - the mechanical strain of bending the bow to store energy will cause it to snap.

There's a reason why siege engines have been torsion-powered or counterweight-powered for since the ancient Greeks. Using an elastic block or weight to store the energy means your throwing arm(s) can be thick enough not to bend and break when the machine performs its intended task.

There is a trick to somewhat exceed the limits of a bow-powered missile thrower - the Multiple Bed Crossbow. Instead of one bow at the limits of the materials available, you have two or three bows with the bowstrings linked to combine their energy:

I doubt they were any better than a similarly-sized torsion arrow shooter such as a cheiroballista though.

Greenfield · Nov 14, 2018

I think the big one could have been made to work. The only change needed would be to change the one thick cross arm into several layered cross arms.

It's essentially the multiple bow you've illustrated, but with the "bow" part made of several layers. Think of closely nested parentheses. )))))

The bows would be so close that they'd slide on one another. The single bowstring or stone sling would be attached to forward most set of arms, and the others would add their power to that one simply by pressing against it.

As it was, trying to flex those huge, thick limbs essentially stretched the outermost face beyond the limits of the materials. They cracked.

Also, as any archer or gunnery officer can tell you, you don't level a siege engine at the target. You aim up, to account for gravity. In their demo the huge crossbow was firing level to the ground, as if it would somehow have a flat trajectory.

Cleon · Nov 15, 2018

Greenfield said:
I think the big one could have been made to work. The only change needed would be to change the one thick cross arm into several layered cross arms.

It's essentially the multiple bow you've illustrated, but with the "bow" part made of several layers. Think of closely nested parentheses. )))))

The bows would be so close that they'd slide on one another. The single bowstring or stone sling would be attached to forward most set of arms, and the others would add their power to that one simply by pressing against it.

That doesn't seem terribly practical to me. A single bowstave built with Renaissance-era technology won't be able to store that much energy without breaking - I'd guesstimate a few hundred Joules - so you'd need an awful lot of them to hurl a grapefruit-sized shot at ballista level velocity.

It would seem difficult if not impossible to squeeze enough into a frame without them getting in each other's way or the whole construct being so large its too cumbersome to be useful.

abe ray · Dec 11, 2018

Would stone giants use it?

Cleon · Dec 15, 2018

abe ray said:
Would stone giants use it?

There wouldn't be any point since their Rock Throwing extraordinary ability is so much better.

abe ray · Jul 14, 2019

Cleon said:
There wouldn't be any point since their Rock Throwing extraordinary ability is so much better.

Thanks, now would other giants(e.g. ogres) use it?

Cleon · Jul 15, 2019

abe ray said:
Thanks, now would other giants(e.g. ogres) use it?

Well if we assume the "same stats as a sling" proposal I made earlier in this thread applies, they could but they probably wouldn't.

A Large sling bullet does 1d6 damage, a Huge one 1d8, while sling stones do 1d4/1d6 at Large/Huge.

All the SRD Giants do more damage with their Rock Throwing (2d6 for the Large Fire/Frost/Hill Giants, 2d8 for the Large Stone Giant and Huge Cloud Giant).

If for some reason we're restricting them to standard ranged weapons instead of rocks, they'd do one or two dice-levels higher damage than a "sling model pellet bow" simply throwing javelins (1d8/2d6 for Large/Huge) like the SRD Ogre uses.

Of course, like any 3E D&D ranged weapon attacker they'd generally be best off for damage and distance with a Strength-bonus composite longbow (2d6/3d6 for Large/Huge) like the SRD Storm Giant uses.

The Giant type is proficient with all simple and martial weapons, so they can all use composite longbows.

Nagol · Jul 15, 2019

Sling staff.

Essentially, it is what it sounds like a sling attached to the end of a staff. The staff provides leverage for harder throws and faster twirling of the larger sling.

D&D General Pellet bow?

Cleon

Legend

Greenfield

Adventurer

Cleon

Legend

abe ray

Explorer

Cleon

Legend

abe ray

Explorer

Cleon

Legend

Nagol

Unimportant

Similar Threads