Spoilers Doctor Who s15 (or 2) [[spoilers!]]

Yeah, I was always dubious about 10 lambasting Harriet over the whole Sycorax thing- the Doctor has done worse, before and since, to his enemies. Seven arranging for Skaro's destruction via the Hand of Omega? Ten himself imprisoning the Family of Blood forever? Or attempting to rewrite history, declaring himself the Time Lord Triumphant because, well, nobody could stop him?
It's jarring because we went from 15 crying over killing Sutekh (who gleefully murdered literally everyone except The Doctor and Ruby throughout all of time and space) during last season's finale to cackling over villain deaths this season.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

It's jarring because we went from 15 crying over killing Sutekh (who gleefully murdered literally everyone except The Doctor and Ruby throughout all of time and space) during last season's finale to cackling over villain deaths this season.
When he calls himself a Madman in a Box, he's not joking. From most perspectives, the Doctor is insane. I don't really expect consistency of action. At any moment, he could be any of the infamous D&D alignments.
 

When he calls himself a Madman in a Box, he's not joking. From most perspectives, the Doctor is insane. I don't really expect consistency of action. At any moment, he could be any of the infamous D&D alignments.
15 was specifically said to be the emotionally put together Doctor in The Giggle.

A Doctor who's had the time to deal with their issues and come to term with them.
 




One of The Doctor's consistent traits has been standing against oppression, especially from powerful institutions. They have repeatedly called out minor abuses of power as being a slippery slope and that just because someone is awful doesn't mean they deserve to die.

Like in Voyage of the Damned where the worst members of the group The Doctor ended up with survived while the best died.

As another character pointed out:

"Of all the people to survive, he's not the one you would have chosen, is he? But if you could choose, Doctor, if you could decide who lives and who dies... that would make you a monster."

In this episode Kate decided to become a monster. Her victim was a reprehensible person, but she still chose to abuse her power over life and death out of spite.

And the show glorifies it.

It says "It's good if the government violates your civil rights if you're a bad person. Conrad was a bad person and got what he deserved. The innocent have nothing to fear. Don't question authorities, they know better. Civil rights are less important than safety."

Every other time a character's said that they're the people The Doctor is trying to take down.
 
Last edited:

One of The Doctor's consistent traits has been standing against oppression, especially from powerful institutions. They have repeatedly called out minor abuses of power as being a slippery slope and that just because someone is awful doesn't mean they deserve to die.

Like in Voyage of the Damned where the worst members of the group The Doctor ended up with survived while the best died.

As another character pointed out:

"Of all the people to survive, he's not the one you would have chosen, is he? But if you could choose, Doctor, if you could decide who lives and who dies... that would make you a monster."

In this episode Kate decided to become a monster. Her victim was a reprehensible person, but she still chose to abuse her power over life and death out of spite.

And the show glorifies it.

It says "It's good if the government violates your civil rights if you're a bad person. Conrad was a bad person and got what he deserved. The innocent have nothing to fear. Don't question authorities, they know better. Civil rights are less important than safety."

Every other time a character's said that they're the people The Doctor is trying to take down.
I have a feeling that Conrad, ultimately, got exactly the opposite of what he deserved. I think that he's gotten power, after having been released, and will end up being a linchpin in what happened to Earth.
 

I have a feeling that Conrad, ultimately, got exactly the opposite of what he deserved. I think that he's gotten power, after having been released, and will end up being a linchpin in what happened to Earth.
Yeah, his rejection of the Doctor's reality went rather well for him, at least for "creepy Mrs Flood cameo" values of 'well'.
 

The Doctor's sense of empathy is obviously on the fritz again. He didn't give a whit about UNIT. He didn't show up to resolve the scenario. He only swung by because Conrad broke Ruby's heart.
 

Remove ads

Top